CC Minutes - 10/27/03 Mtg - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

point Eric Forrest to Position 5 on the Budget Committee. Roll call vote; the vote on the motion resulted in a tie, 4:4; councilors Nathanson, Bettman, Kelly, and Taylor voting in favor, and councilors Solomon, Meisner, Pap6, and Poling voting in opposi- tion. Mayor Torrey cast a vote in opposition and the motion failed on a final vote of 5:4. Councilor Kelly said, given he was unaware of the change in vote, he would oppose the reappointment of Mr. Forrest. Councilor Bettman concurred with Councilor Kelly. She felt the process had been manipulated, though not intentionally. She stated that she had voted for Mr. Forrest's reappointment initially because he did a good job and participated in the process well. She noted that more often than not she disagreed with him, but asserted he was articulate and always came to committee meetings prepared. She opined that strong business and development advocates were over-represented on the Budget Committee. She felt there needed to be a broader political spectrum. Councilor Pap~ agreed with Councilor Bettman on Mr. Forrest's record as a Budget Committee member. He did not feel that any manipulation had occurred. He said he had heard at the beginning of the work session that one councilor had changed a vote. Councilor Solomon disagreed with the notion that the process had been manipulated. She related that she had initially been the only person to vote for one applicant and had switched her vote as a result. She commented, regarding the balance on the committee, that just because a person was a business leader did not make them unable to understand social service issues, asserting that many business leaders donated substantial sums of money to social service providers. Councilor Meisner preferred the motion be made to reflect the sentiments registered in the straw poll. He stressed that neither candidate, a school principal and a former minister turned public defender, could be accurately characterized as having a particular business or development interest. Councilor Bettman agreed that the business community contributed generously and that the less public dollars available, the more the social service providers were starved for donations from businesses. Roll call vote; the motion passed, 7:1; Councilor Taylor voting in opposition. Councilor Pap~, seconded by Councilor Nathanson, moved to appoint Robert Peters to Position 3 on the Budget Committee for a three-year term beginning November 1, 2003, and ending on October 31, 2006. Councilor Bettman conveyed her support for the motion. She expressed admiration for the work of Maurice Denner, the other applicant under consideration for the position. She related that she had worked with Mr. Denner on the Police Commission for the past three years and called him an asset to any committee. However, she asserted that Mr. Denner was a staunch supporter of the Eugene Police Department (EPD), suggesting that Mr. Peters would bring a broader view to the budget process. Councilor Pap~ disagreed. He felt Mr. Denner had a broad view of many issues and brought with him a firm background in budget development from his career in public education. He noted the applicants had MINUTES--Eugene City Council October 27, 2003 Page 8 Regular Meeting