CCMinutes - 01/12/04 Mtg - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

In closing, Ms. Jensen expressed the willingness of the Eugene Kennel Club to aid in the crafting and establishment of nuisance regulations. Michael Carrigan, 1430 West 4th Avenue, expressed concern about the right to assemble as specified in Ordinance 20303. He felt the language in the ordinance that required a permit for a gathering of 25 or more people would hinder citizens' First Amendment right to assemble. He objected to obtaining a permit. He felt that, should there be concerns regarding scheduling of two events at the same place, a reservation system could resolve these concerns. He advocated for creating such a system with no payment, no signature, no insurance requirement and suggested that the City would be held harmless for injuries or other damages. Karl Sorg, 1555 West 18th Avenue, said he had moved to Eugene from Washington, DC, in 1992 upon retirement from a 45-year career in law and that his specialty had been civil rights. He noted that he had taught constitutional law for eight years at the University of Northern Illinois. He opposed the language in Ordinance 20303 that required obtaining a permit for a gathering of 25 or more people in the downtown area. He called the language ~unconstitutional." Eric Gross, 1544 Alder Street, # 51, asserted the language that requires a permit for a gathering of 25 or more people in Ordinance 20303 violated First Amendment rights. He lauded the rights of citizens of the United States to assemble freely and to petition the government for redress of grievances as one of the things that ~makes this country great." He alleged that the permits cost money and some people may not be able to afford it. He felt that a ~government bureaucrat" could exercise discretionary privileges in granting such a permit. He advocated for removal of the permit requirement from the ordinance. Mason Goch~, 411 Knoop Lane, explained that he was a new voter. He felt voters would respond to the requirement for a permit in Ordinance 20303 by voting out those who approved of it. Al Phillips, PO Box 2146, provided the City Council with copies of the minority report from the LCARA Task Force, written by Dr. Sandra Smalley. He also provided a packet of information written by Dr. Eugene Skoals, former Dean of the School of Law, which had also been distributed to the Lane Board of County Commissioners. He said Dr. Skoals' paper pointed out ~all of the fallacies, the potential legal problems, and the unconstitutional problems" in the report from the task force. He alleged that Sheriff Clemens had expressed reservations about the ordinance because it allegedly would arm animal control officers, and give them the right of search and seizure without a warrant. Gordie Albi, 1696 Adkins Street, #2, spoke about the constitutionality of the requirement for a permit for a gathering of 25 or more people ensconced in the language of Ordinance 20303. She opposed the requirement, alleging that it would %ompromise" the constitution. She related that she had lived in countries that were war zones. She felt the City government should trust citizens and should not deny the right to speak or assemble. Saskia Wittson, 2682 Madison Street, said she was 14 years old. She read the First Amendment of the Constitution of the United States aloud. David Hanson, 2738 Kismet Way, advocated for the establishment of local housing standards to ensure accessibility to the Oregon Landlord/Tenant Act. He said the act provided basic guidelines for acceptable MINUTES--Eugene City Council January 12, 2004 Page 3 Regular Meeting