HomeMy WebLinkAboutCC Minutes - 01/07/08 State of the City
M I N U T E S
Eugene City Council
State of the City
Hult Center for the Performing Arts
January 7, 2008
5:30 p.m.
COUNCILORS PRESENT: Andrea Ortiz, Chris Pryor, Betty Taylor, Bonny Bettman, Jennifer Solomon,
George Poling, Mike Clark, Alan Zelenka.
I. WELCOME AND INTRODUCTIONS
Council President Andrea Ortiz welcomed those present at the 2008 State of the City. She said that all those
present made Eugene a great place to be. She recognized the public officials present at the event. She
welcomed the students present from Eugene’s Sister City Chinju, Korea, who stood to be recognized.
II. MUSICAL SELECTION
Those present heard a musical selection entitled Dancing Bear by Tonn Nua Celtic Band, which included
members Ansel Dow, Daphne Garcia, David Garcia, Zoe Garcia, and Alison Helser.
III. CITY COUNCILOR REMARKS
Ms. Bettman, Ward 1, welcomed those present and thanked the mayor for allowing the councilors to speak.
She expressed appreciation to all those present for their participation. She noted that the mayor would soon
celebrate the positive achievements of the past year, and she shared her pride in the City’s achievements.
However, she perceived systematic problems that would continue to undermine progress and sustainable
change and hoped they could be addressed in 2008.
Ms. Bettman offered the following for facilitating progress. She proposed the creation of the office of
independent auditor to provide data, research, and information to public officials; she noted the risk that such
an office could be diluted in the initiative process, and suggested her fears were well-founded in the opposition
of the administration to an independent police oversight process with authority or power. She suggested that
the administration manipulated an outcome to minimize the power of the police auditor and civilian review
board, although it was better than nothing and most people were satisfied with the outcome. She said the
independent auditor could face the same fate of providing a façade of accountability superimposed over
“business as usual,” delaying true reform for decades. She advocated for an external professional auditor’s
office with a caveat that the public must be informed and vigilant to ensure true accountability.
Ms. Bettman called for the City Manager to create an in-house city attorney’s office. She said the City needed
such a fully staffed office to save money and eliminate conflicts on the part of the existing firm, which
represented many other clients who often had interests contradictory to the City’s. She said it was not an
adverse judgment on the existing firm; it merely had too many bosses, and Eugene deserved attorneys
MINUTES—State of the City January 7, 2008 Page 1
dedicated to the community’s best interest. She said the council should direct the City Manager to establish
such an office by motion.
Ms. Bettman advocated for hiring a new city manager with extensive experience and leadership ability who
had ideas and the skills to implement them. That individual should find where common ground existed among
councilors and develop it for the benefit of all rather than exploiting differences and pitting factions against
each other to barely pass initiatives divisive to the community. She called for leadership which confidently
embraced reform and innovation and was not afraid of its citizens.
Ms. Bettman advocated for abolishment of the existing urban renewal districts in favor of existing mechanisms
that assisted in the development of housing. She thought urban renewal districts were a disincentive to
sensitive development because property owners hold out in hopes of “cashing in” for huge public subsidies,
and in the meantime the urban core was suffering from inattention. She pointed out it only required a council
majority to increase the spending limit. Once the districts were ended, the community could still suffer the
impacts of urban renewal tax diversion because of the many districts in the state that used urban renewal and
diverted money away from Eugene students and State services. She said Eugene still had work to do at the
State legislature so that schools and other jurisdictions could “opt out” of other cities and counties’ urban
renewal tax diversion programs for funding their “pet projects.” She believed her four initiatives would
contribute positively to every issue citizens cared about.
Ms. Bettman ended with a quote from Franklin Delano Roosevelt: “The only sure bulwark of continuing
liberty is a government strong enough to protect the interests of the people, and a people strong enough and
well-enough informed to maintain its sovereign control over its government.”
Ms. Taylor, Ward 2, agreed with Ms. Bettman’s remarks about a performance auditor and in-house attorney.
She expressed the wish that each councilor could give an award. The first she would give was to the citizens
who worked to defeat the increase in the urban renewal debt and protect businesses downtown. She was glad
that no downtown business had to move unless they wished to.
Ms. Taylor believed it was a good year for citizen activity, citing the Amazon Headwaters supporters’ work to
persuade the council to exercise eminent domain for property containing some of the headwaters. She also
cited the work of the Crest neighbors in getting context-sensitive design for their streets, the work of the
Madison Meadows neighbors who succeeded in saving a green space in their neighborhood as other examples
to be commended.
Ms. Taylor said she would like to see the Amazon Headwaters protected and in public ownership. She hoped
the council hired a competent city manager and passed a living wage ordinance. She suggested the council
could allow free parking downtown.
In the long-range, Ms. Taylor wished success to the Beam project. She hoped to see work begin on a youth
center and called for a philanthropist to support in that effort.
Ms. Taylor suggested the City modify its motto and be a “great city for the arts and outdoors.”
Ms. Ortiz, Ward 7, observed that the State of the City event gave those without a lot of time to spare a
snapshot of how the City was doing. She thanked her family for its support and said her husband Neno and
sons Neno, Raoul, and Emilo who were the most important people in her life. Her immediate family kept her
humble, laughing, and crying. Ms. Ortiz said her work family at Peace Health was also important. Her job
MINUTES—State of the City January 7, 2008 Page 2
reminded her of how insignificant she was and that she was part of a bigger puzzle. Her job reminded her of
how blessed she was with good health, a home, the ability to pay her bills, a car, and a loving family. Most
people took that for granted. Ms. Ortiz believed her position on the council gave her the position to speak
truth when others could not.
Ms. Ortiz offered the following quote: “Believe that there is no limit but the sky.”
IV. AWARDS AND RECOGNITION
?
Community Service Awards
Mayor Piercy acknowledged the contribution of co-chairs Greg McLauchlan and Harriett Cherry of the West
Broadway Advisory Committee and spoke of the work done by the committee. She thanked Mr. McLauchlan
and Ms. Cherry and presented them with the Community Service Award. She also thanked committee
members present and asked them to stand to be recognized.
Mayor Piercy acknowledged the contribution of co-chair Tina Rinaldi of the Cultural Policy Review
Committee and spoke of the work of the committee. She thanked Ms. Rinaldi and presented her with the
Community Service Award. She also noted the leadership of co-chair David Kelly, who was not present.
Mayor Piercy asked other committee members to stand to be recognized. She also noted the contribution of
Wolf Brown consultants in creating the committee’s final report and recommendations.
Mayor Piercy acknowledged the contribution of Marilyn Milne and Sara Mazze of the Mayor’s Climate
Challenge Committee and presented them with the Community Service Award. She encouraged those present
to visit sustaineugene.com and commit to the challenge. Mayor Piercy also acknowledged the contributions of
the University of Oregon’s Climate Leadership Initiative, led by Bob Doppelt. She also asked Dave Funk,
Mary Van Noy, and Kelly Hale to stand to be recognized as part of the climate challenge.
?
Employee Recognition Award
Mayor Piercy recognized Michelle Mortenson, Public Service Specialist, and Isaac Markehe, Neighborhood
Program Manager, for their contributions to the City in 2007.
?
Mayor’s Sustainability Award
Mayor Piercy presented the Mayor’s Sustainability Award to Mark Raney of Cumulus Broadcasting, noting
the company’s contribution to the Sustainable Business Initiative, which resulted in free public service
announcements about sustainability practices being broadcast on Cumulus stations. She thanked Michael
O’Shea of Cumulus and community members Dave Funk, Sheriza Gerry, Jennifer Bell, Roger Ebbage, Sara
Mazze, and for their contributions to the effort.
V. POETRY READING
Those present heard a poem by Ari Lesser entitled Global Warming, performed by Iana Matthew-Harris, Ari
Lesser, and Ishi Woods.
MINUTES—State of the City January 7, 2008 Page 3
VI. SPECIAL PRESENTATION
Bill Drumheller, Oregon Department of Energy, provided a special presentation on the International Council
for Local Environmental Initiatives Greenhouse Gas Inventory.
VII. MUSICAL SELECTION
Those present heard another musical selection by Tonn Nua Celtic Band entitled The Gaelic Song.
VIII. STATE OF THE CITY ADDRESS
Mayor Piercy delivered the following remarks:
Good evening everyone and thank you for joining us here in our beautiful Hult Center for the Performing
Arts. Let me take this opportunity to thank our citizens, our council and our staff for all their efforts in
2007 to keep Eugene such a great place to call home.
Like many of you, I start off most days by listening to the radio, reading the newspaper and checking the
web.
Like you, I am acutely aware of the ever-rising death toll in Iraq, the ever-rising temperature of the earth,
the fretful American economy and the resulting financial challenges we face at home.
And, I am more committed than ever to doing everything we can to work for peace and justice, to reduce our
impact on global warming, to keep our economy strong, and to provide the services our community expects.
I believe absolutely in the power we have individually and collectively to make change, influence policy and
set the direction for the future. Cities are where it all happens; where people live, work, raise families, and
establish roots. Eugene is our city and our home. It is a reflection of our values and how we want this
world to be.
A lot of our work occurs at the City Council table, through advocacy groups, on committees and commis-
sions, and in our neighborhoods. Our energy and passion for civic engagement is a tremendous community
asset, allowing us to address more issues in greater depth.
Essential to our civic engagement are our neighborhood associations. I am impressed with the ever more
active and successful role they are taking to bring forward community perspectives and expertise, whether
it’s on mixed-use development, infill and neighborhood livability, safer parks, railroad pollution, response
to traffic fatalities, or protecting headwaters.
Civic engagement almost always comes with differences of opinion and the issues we face are often thorny.
To me, the important thing is to work together - to find points of common agreement so that we can move
forward as a community. Some recent examples of successful community cooperation are the Mayor’s
Sustainable Business Initiative and the West Eugene Collaborative.
MINUTES—State of the City January 7, 2008 Page 4
The Sustainable Business Initiative brought together a very broad-based group of people with economic, social
and environmental expertise, to make recommendations on how the City of Eugene could support and
encourage the growth of businesses that produce sustainable products such as alternative energy, alternative
fuel, green building, recycling, alternative transportation and health care, natural foods and products. The task
force was also charged with making recommendations that would support and encourage all businesses to use
sustainable practices that reflect the triple bottom line of protecting our natural resources, building social
equity and ensuring economic well-being. Their 22 recommendations, supported by the entire task force and
adopted by our City Council, included establishing an Office of Sustainability and a Sustainability Commission.
Both the office and commission are now firmly in place.
Then, there was the decades-long, acrimonious debate over the West Eugene Parkway. It was clear that the
funding for this project was simply not there and that federal approval was likely never to occur. I asked
business owners, environmentalists, neighbors, agencies, and elected officials to join together to start afresh
and come up with do-able solutions for the vexing West Eugene traffic and transportation problems. They
responded by forming the West Eugene Collaborative. We are working together to make recommendations
on how local governing bodies can solve the longstanding traffic and transportation challenges in West
Eugene while protecting our biologically rich wetlands.
Another one of our city’s current issues is the reinvigoration of downtown. We’ve had differences of opinion
on how best to accomplish this and an election on one proposed course of action is now behind us. It is time
to bridge our differences and form a plan that the whole community will support. I urge all those involved
and interested in the future of our downtown to work for common ground. We can take the energy and
continued commitment of the Citizens for Public Accountability, Chamber of Commerce, and hundreds of
other community members and, together, bring life to our downtown, the heart of our city. The valuable
work of West Broadway Advisory Committee can help inform the discussion. It is within our reach.
One of the reasons I am so optimistic about our downtown is that much of it is already doing well. Fifth
Street, East Broadway and most of Oak, Charnelton, Pearl, Willamette and Olive are busy and full. The
Beam redevelopment of Center Court and the Washburn Building is on the table. We have new businesses
on Broadway and Enterprise is moving into the refurbished “Bon Marche” building. KLCC is moving in
th
just a block away on 8 Avenue and Oregon Research Institute has a renewed interest in establishing a
presence in downtown.
Yes, we do have those two pits and empty storefronts - and lots of visitors coming to town. In the short run,
we can focus public safety efforts on our problem blocks, address rundown storefronts, tweak codes,
increase cultural and recreational activities in the area, and look at parking restrictions. I intend to walk
into each business in that two-block area to either thank them for looking good or to see how improvements
can be made. This is something we must take on together.
Those short-term fixes will help keep the momentum going and build a base for a wide-range of exciting
possibilities. We need to put the two problem blocks in the context of our entire downtown: opportunities
for a new city hall, expansion of The Shedd, the development of a new Courthouse area, Franklin Boulevard
improvements and, with EWEB’s anticipated move, new connections to the river. Let’s roll up our sleeves
and keep going.
I am proud of the many services and amenities the City provides: our parks, open spaces and bike paths in
every part of the community, and our stewardship of valuable natural resources. Most recently, we were the
first city in Oregon to receive Forest Legacy funding in order to preserve 25 acres of Oak habitat at Wild
MINUTES—State of the City January 7, 2008 Page 5
Iris Ridge. That’s a great accomplishment!
It is our wealth of arts and outdoors assets that makes this community so special and this year offers an
exceptional opportunity to highlight both.
th
In September, we celebrated the 25 Anniversary of this beautiful facility and offered 5,443 free admissions
to a variety of events. Our beloved library, which has quickly become a cornerstone of our downtown, just
th
celebrated its 5 birthday. Over 3,000 people participated in a Cultural Policy Review and the council has
adopted strategies that will strengthen both our city’s and community’s cultural offerings and our
commitment to the arts. Galleries are thriving - and not just on First Fridays – and local musicians and
performers provide a diverse range of entertainment in unique local venues.
We took pride in the achievements of the University of Oregon and the Ducks as they gained national
attention and acclaim for Eugene (even that pugnacious mascot). The University logged permits for more
than $43 million in building projects in Eugene this year. And a hard working coalition not only brought the
2008 Olympic Track & Field Trials back to Hayward Field, re-establishing our reputation as Track City
USA, but Eugene has also been chosen to host the U.S. national track championships in 2009 and 2011 and
the 2012 Olympic Track & Field Trials. The huge community engagement efforts in planning for the
Olympic Trials, the events leading up to them, and the strategies to engage our young people were
instrumental in ensuring that Eugene is Track City USA –forever. I want to give special thanks to our
interim city manager Angel Jones for her key role in this success. I also want to thank all our partners in the
coalition who are doing a wonderful job of working together to maximize this opportunity for our commu-
nity: the University of Oregon, City of Springfield, CVALCO, Lane County, State of Oregon, and Lane
Transit District, as well as numerous businesses and hundreds of volunteers. Thanks to their efforts, this
event is shaping up to be one of the biggest, most exciting, and most fun events in Eugene’s recent history. I
encourage you all to get involved, support it, or simply enjoy it.
On another front, Eugene continues to address the critical need for affordable and low-income housing. The
th
most recent project is nearing completion in our downtown: WestTown on 8, with its new innovative
work/live units. Eugene adopted a stronger manufactured home ordinance to protect owners of this
important affordable housing stock. We provided funds for shelter and transportation for the homeless and
the Mayor’s Blue Ribbon Committee on Homelessness has been working hard on how we can provide
services and reduce the numbers of those who are homeless or face the threat of homelessness. A one-day
Project Homeless Connect event in February provided services and connections for over a thousand of the
area’s homeless and a second one is scheduled for next month. Staff, social services, governing bodies, and
hundreds of volunteers and donations make this event meaningful on every level.
In July, our independent police auditor, Cris Beamud, officially opened her doors downtown and the
Civilian Review Board is in place, working on complaints. Both have become an important part of ensuring
justice in our community.
Police staffing needs remain an issue before us and that problem is compounded by the inadequate funding
of Lane County’s prevention, intervention and treatment services, jail beds, legal, and judicial processes.
While Eugeneans are committed to community policing, the county public safety system itself is broken. We
will have to be very strategic in our prioritizations in order to effectively address this critical issue.
Loss of federal, state and county road repair dollars also continues to plague us and our pothole backlog
grows. At my request, the council worked together to bring very diverse perspectives to the table and
MINUTES—State of the City January 7, 2008 Page 6
develop a funding package that included a gas tax increase. Although the tax increase did not survive the
last election, we understand the growing need and will keep working on finding solutions that the community
will support.
No look at local issues is complete without some mention of the hospital saga. While neither the council nor
I can legally comment on the location proposed by McKenzie-Willamette in north Eugene, I can reiterate my
strong support for the presence of two full-service hospitals in our metropolitan area, which will ensure
healthy competition and breadth of services. McKenzie-Willamette should be in Eugene where it can
effectively provide health care for our community, support our tax base and where, if needed, we can have
some influence on significant health care policies.
I am proud of our continued efforts to guarantee the right and access to services for all our community
members, regardless of race, age, gender, sexual orientation, abilities, beliefs, or income. We want this
community to be a comfortable place for everyone to live, work and raise their families, where differences
are respected and thought of as a valued part of the fabric of a strong community. It hurt last year when
our city experienced repeated incidents of hate speech and the defacing of important religious objects. Our
community will stand united against such behavior, and defend the rights of all its members.
Same sex couples still pursue the same legal rights as married couples; clearly the day has come to end all
forms of discrimination based on sexual orientation. As you are probably aware, an opportunity to take one
more step in achieving this goal of equality was recently frustrated when a new domestic partnership law
was postponed by the courts. Despite these setbacks, however, we must continue to be vigilant in pursuing
equal rights for all.
Differences of opinion about immigration issues can fuel bigotry and hatred; we need to remind ourselves
that our community and our nation were built by indigenous peoples and immigrants, and that all human
beings deserve respect.
The social justice triumphs and defeats of this last year have increased my resolve to continue working on
becoming an official Human Rights City, one that embraces human rights in every decision we make. If
there’s any place in America that can do this, it is certainly here.
Eugene has a commitment to being the most sustainable community possible. We know that with finite
resources and growing climate change challenges, we must scale up this commitment as a matter of both City
policy and in the consciousness and actions of the larger community.
This past year, we hired the City’s first sustainability manager and the members of the new Sustainability
Commission have now been appointed. We will update our community greenhouse gas inventory in April.
We know that over the last eight years, through the purchase of hybrids and bio diesel, City government has
decreased its CO2 emissions by 10 %. The methane we capture at our wastewater plant provides half the
power it needs. Through LED lighting, recycling, wind power purchase, bus passes, bike programs, e-
communications, and a whole range of other strategies, Eugene has taken strides toward carbon neutrality
and zero waste. We still have a long way to go. Large reductions in building and transportation emissions
are the only way we can seriously impact climate change.
I have enjoyed working hand in hand with mayors across this country (now over 800) in support of the U.S.
Mayor’s Climate Protection Agreement, using our mutual power to push for changes at the Congressional
level. While the situation we face as a planet is serious, I see major cities such as New York, Los Angeles
MINUTES—State of the City January 7, 2008 Page 7
and Chicago combining their purchasing powers for green solutions and to create green jobs at home - jobs
that help put sustainable practices in place, are built on social equity, and pay well.
In Oregon, Governor Kulongoski has embraced sustainable jobs and practices as the basis for Oregon’s
economy, much as we have been doing here. He hopes that Oregon can offer leadership on a number of
fronts and I want Eugene to be a significant part of this work. It is no coincidence that Sequential BioFuels
is located here, and that the largest solar panel display in the state is on one of our industrial roofs.
The governor has also required every state department including ODOT to do their part to reduce carbon
emissions. As we approach all new regional planning efforts in transportation and land use, the state
requirements give me hope. Necessity is the mother of invention and may help ODOT respond to climate
change and finite resources, allowing it to be more creative and energy-conscious, rather than simply laying
more roads.
The challenges are great and so are the possibilities.
I know 2008 will be a very challenging year at every level. We must continue to build on the momentum we
have to address the major issues nationally and locally. We have the talent, the heart and the chutzpah. We
are, after all, Eugene.
Thus, my to-do list for 2008 includes the following goals:
• Eugene leads in sustainable practices and supports the growth of sustainable businesses as a
key to strengthening our economy;
• Eugene continues to implement the Sustainable Business Initiative recommendations, moving
toward carbon neutrality and zero waste;
• Eugene develops a climate protection strategic plan;
• The West Eugene Collaborative (WEC )completes its recommendations for addressing traffic
and transportation issues in west Eugene;
• Eugene reviews the recommendations of the Blue Ribbon Committee on Homelessness and ef-
fective goals and strategies are adopted;
• We collaborate and successfully plan for downtown, increasing the pace of reinvigoration of
West Broadway;
• Eugene addresses its neighborhood pothole backlog;
• Eugene advances the Cultural Policy Review’s strategies to increase support for arts and cul-
ture;
• Eugene and our partners host a hugely successful and green Olympic Track & Field Trials;
• Eugene considers an independent auditor for the City of Eugene;
MINUTES—State of the City January 7, 2008 Page 8
• McKenzie-Willamette Hospital locates in Eugene;
• Our new city manager is on the job and is exceptional;
• Eugene adopts a youth advisory board respecting the voices, talents and needs of our young
people;
• Eugene and its partners collaborate on the protection and restoration of the Amazon Creek ba-
sin and headwaters and build upon the success of the wetlands with the creation of the Envi-
ronmental Education Center; and
• Eugene moves toward becoming an official Human Rights City.
My comments tonight and the goals I outlined have focused on the main issues of the day and on who we are
as a community. I could go on for hours!
I know we can successfully bring people together to work on our most difficult and challenging issues. We
must keep the proverbial “pedal to the metal” so we can hold on to what is wonderful about this place we
call home. Our future depends on it.
IX. ADJOURN
The meeting adjourned at 6:45 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Angel Jones
City Manager pro tem
(Recorded by Kimberly Young)
MINUTES—State of the City January 7, 2008 Page 9