HomeMy WebLinkAbout06/15/1972 Meeting
\
Council Chamber
Eugene, Oregon
June 15, 1972
.X Adjourned meeting of the Common Council of , the city of ,Eugene, Oregon - adjourned from the
meeting of JUne 12,1972 - was called to orqer by His Honor Mayor Lester E. Anderson at'7:30 p.m.
on June 15, 1972 in the Council Chamber with the following councilmen present: Mr. Mohr,
Mrs. Beal, Messrs. McDonald, Teague" Williams, HersJmer, and Bradshaw. -, Mrs. Campbell,was absent.
Continuation of agenda for June 12, 1972 meeting:
I - ITEMS ~-CONSIDERED WITH ONE MOTION
P~eviously discussed at committee meetings.'op' M~y--24~ 1972-~aj:t:,2, (Preserit::MS:lyo11 Ahqerson;
Councilmen Mohr, Campbell, and Bradshaw); May- 31, -1972 (Present: Mayor ,- Anderson; Council-
men Mohr, B'eal, Williams, Hershner, Campbell, and Bradshaw); and June 7, 1972 (Present:
Mayor Anderson; Councilmen Mohr, Beal, ,Teague, Williams, Hershner, Campbell, and Bradshaw).
Minutes of those meetings appear below printed in ~talics.
A. Planning COnmUssion Report - May 15, 1972
1. Reconsideration of zone change from RA to R-2 PD, southeast corner Norkenzie
and Minda (Richard Miles
2. Reconsideration of zone change from RA to R-2, northeast corner 18th and
Bailey Hill Road (Michael Safley) ,
Planning Commission reaffirmed its recommend~tion to deny both zone changes.
Comm
tf'\ Mr. Bradshaw moved seconded by Mrs. Campbell to confirm the Planning COnmUs- 5/24/72
sion recommendation. Motion carried unanimously. Approve
B. Mall Regulations - A proposed ordinance, copies of which were previously dis-
tributed to Council members, would bett;er deal wi th kinds of acti vi ties and per-
missions in use of the_ downtown mall, and cure some legal insufficiencies' of the
present'ordlnance. Manager said it might be well to refer the ordinance to a
broadly based ad hoc ci tizens commi ttee for recommendations, and thereby avoid
controversy at a public hearing. He explained changes from the present ordinance -
climbing, to control "safety problems; fountain, so that persons may not throw
trash or use other than for wading or observing; fund raising; seeing-eye dogs
will be allowed; different-procedure for granting permits for use of the mall,
and providing appeal from failure to obtain a permit. Manager said if the
Council does, not wish to est,ablish an ad hoc committee, perhaps an administrative
hearing could pe held to at least, give interested persons an opportunity to re-
I act and give some input prior to official Council consideration. With regard to
legal, insufficiency, Manager said the City Attorn?yfeels the present, <;Jrdinance
I is unenforceable since it was adopted on the basis ,of a set of rules, and a
violation of those_rules becomes a violation of the ordinance.
Councilm~n Mohr~ecommended holding,an,ad~nistrative hearing designed to
. eli ci t reasons for the changes in the ordinance, administrati ve _ experien<;:e wi th
the present rules, and answers to questions with debate in a way not possible
at a committee or public hearing. Mrs. Beal suggested people having an interest
in the m{ill regulations should be notified of such hearing to allow ex<?hange of
I views at that time rather than at a public hearing. Manager said there would
be an effort made to gain widespread participation.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mr. Williams that Manager set up an administrative
bearing on the proposed mall regulations ordinance. Motion carried unanimousl.y.
Mrs. Beal asked if the Manager would conduct the hearing with the Council attend-
ing but not acting. Manager said from the staff standpoint it would be helpful
for various departments dealing wit~ mall problems to participate to allow ex-
change 6f their problems and problems of people using the mall. Mayor Anderson Comm
said it should be understood the administrati ve hearing will not precl ude a 5/31/72
public hearing. Approve
C. Downtown Development District Board - Councilman Mohr distributed to other Council
members a memo containing his thoughts with regard to certain sections of the
proposed ordinance establish~ng a governing board for the Downtown Development
District. He suggests a definition of the Board's purpose to include other than
. financing and administering the: District, especially to include alternate forms
of transportationp and a limitation on the sorts of programs that the revenues
could be used to support. He also,suggested that membership include at least
two Council members and that the additional appointments be made in the same
manner as those for the Eugene Renewal Agency; and that grievances appealed
from Board decisionsb~ directed to the Council rather than to the City Manager.
Mr. Mohr said he would like to see a Council subconmUttee afJpointed to work with
the Downtown Association committee in drafting the ordinance creating the board.
I /p '" 6/15/72 - 1
Councilm~Williams said he feels it is a question of whether provision of park-
ing by the business communi ty downtown is something they are doing and availing
themsel,ves of the tax system in so doing, or an overall public service wi th any
number of other public activities involved. Mrs. Beal said she feels the implica- -
tions_go beyond a group of people allocating taxes to themselves; the question _.
may',hav.et.o,~e resoJ,.ved-whether this kind of organization is necessary if it is
.to b~ l~mited onlyt~,additional tax ,for parking.
- ,
Manager said one of the key elements in Mr. 'Jacbbs' presentation of the background
for creation of the district was that if it is assumed that the downtown area has
to be maintained in an economically strong position and that transportation in
general and promotion are part of that process, some method is needed which makes
it mandatory that those people who are benefitted will participate. He ,said it
was - fouil,d in surveyimjsimilar programs in th€? California cities v~sited that
un~versal participation is _ th.e key_ to the succ,ess of the program. , $ince the City
is the only agency which has legal way of guarant_eeing that universal participa-
tion, the creation of a board wi th legal authori ty to develop financing seems to
be the only alternative. This ordinance creates that bOdy-and needs to use the
power of the pUblic if the program is to be carried out. Manage:r: ;s~id it is _
generally felt that if the program is to work it must absorb and pay the assess-
ment on the 10th and Oak garage because the City cannot be expected to set up a
free parking district and also. pay. bonds on the Overpark.
Mrs. Beal wondered if the Downtown committee has considered alternatives to park-
ing, whether they -have thought of less expensive parking, shuttle busses, special
arra,ngements wi_ th the bus company, package deli very. .
Vince Farina, member of the Downtown committee~ tiaid even with mass transit, park-
ing will be need~d.. He said people within the proposed district are willing to
pay a business license fee or ad valorem tax for the very specific purpose of sol v-
ing the parking, problem as well as to promote business, downtown. . He said the
business pro[llOtion downtown is what will bring property values back and will con-
seque.ntl,y benefit the entire City.
Mrs. Beal _remarked on the aspect of air pollution connected with parking and the
use qf. ?utomobi~e.s.~n _the congested area of the City, aside from the blacktopped
areas, needed to accommodate tlle parking,: She felt there should be some study on
the impact of the propo~al in that sense.
Mrs. Campbell was concerned that the tax would_be recovered from the consumer by
an increase in the price of merchandise. Mr. Farina replied that the cost of doing
business mu~t be borne by the cons~mer; in order to realize a profit the cost,of
operation must be overcome. He said there may be some difference between prices
in the downtown area and those in Valley River, but it is debatable; the customers I
pay the cost of parking at Valley River since the merchants there pass the cost on
the same as any other merchant. He t?aid there would have to be some price adjustment,
how much it is not known, becaus-ethe formula is one of the problems to be worked out .
by the proposed board.
Harry Ritchie, owner of stores both at Valley River and in the downtown area, said
prices are the same 'at both stores but business at Valley River has continually
increased whereas in the downtown store the volume has, gone down. Comment9 from
customers always revol ve around lack of or diffi cul ty in parking. He said
several, other programs were explored at great length wi th the concl usion that com-
pulsory participation in a free parking program is necessary. He noted that tenants
in Valley River pay the parking assessment as part of the lease. Mr. Ritchie ,con-
tinued,that all ,of the merchants in the proposed district who are dependent upon I
parking are vitally interested in the program.
Manager sa,id,it has'been previously discussed that before any funding program is
implemented, this Council would expect to have proof of substantial agreement on
the plan prior to public hearing, and that no action would be taken on a request
from ten people to impose a charge on everyone. Mr. Mohr said for that reason it
is very important that a subcommittee of the Council should participate in drafting
th,? program.
Councilman Williams_wondered whether the Council shQuld participate in the drafting
of a financing program, saying that Valley Ri ver and other shopping areas wi thin
the City do_not_have Council participation. He said there is littie question that -
in terms 'of commercial health, growing and expanding, cost of parking- is of concern. ",'
Movement of commercial activities to suburban areas testifies to that. But he does
not agree that in_the downtoTt!n area parking is not a matter of business c~ncern and
is a matter ofCouneil c6iwern when the Council has no say in what shopping centers
provide in the way of parking. He feels the position of the City is to give the
businessmen the opportunity to provide that parking.
J~7 6/15/72 - 2
Mr. Mohr said he can't disagree with that context, but he feels public policy
problems must result from any sort of program such as the one proposed. He
cited the instance of rerouting of the Roosevelt Freeway as a result of the
location of'Valley River Center. He concurred on the iss ue of free parking as
- a business stimulus, but felt major questions would resut such as street im-
provements,. lighting, traffic, etc. Mr. Williams said in dealing with the question
of funding parking on a downtown basis he does not think the 'public policy issues
enumerated would be of concern. Manager said it would be a matter of public concern
in that income of the,_ City from its existing parking program, both on- and off":'street,
will be affected. So there needs to be City participation in the plan to be de-
veloped, either through CounCilor City staff partiCipation.
Mrs. Beal' asked on what basis the proposed assessment is to'be levied. Manager
replied this has not been deCided and is one of the reasons for creating the
board - to have someone to put the program. together. He said discussion has been
general in terms of a business license fee or prop~rty tax.
CounCilman Hershner said to the degree that a good deal of parking is generated
by governmental activities public interest should be involved in the downtown
parking situation, and for that reason the Council should participate in structure
of the board.
Mayor Anderson said he feels the City government in Eugene is committed to a
program which will establish downtown business, particularly retail, as a viable,
competitive 'center, and that 'he strongly feels this Council is obligated to assist
. any groups in the downtown area who through their -own initiative want to improve
parking facilities. Since the City established the shopping mall it is-committed
also to providing faCilities.to make that'a viable center, and cannot establish
a roadblock against the automobile. He said he would be inclined to favor the
proposal, 'of, establishing a -subcommittee to' work with the Downtown committee.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal to establish a three-member subcommittee of
the Council to work with a subcommittee of the Downtown Association in creation Comm
of a Downtown Development District Board" to - include a City staff member'as ex,', 5/31/72
offiCio for liaison. Motion carried unanimously. Approve
D. Withdrawal from, 'City portion of Somerset> Hills, Annexation (Hawkins Lane area) ',-
Councilman Mohr asked that ,the' Council. refex_- to - theP lanning Commission for comment
, and recommendation a request for withdrawal from the City of a portion of the area
I recently annexed along wi th the Breeden Brothers Somerset West development, lying
I along Hawkins Lane south of 22nd and west of City view. He said the area was
I annexed through procedural error,:so the_ City should bear the responsibility of
initiating withdrawal rather than through petition.. of, the, residents. Time ele-
ment is involved because a rezoning petition for property in that area is scheduled
for hearing before the Planning commission at itscnext meeting.
>,1- . .',
Manager explained tha,t the City recommended to the Boundary Commission, in order
,. to gain a.better cOnfiguration of City limits, that it add that portion to the
I Somerset annexation. No public notice or hearing was held. The area logically Comm
should be within the City, he said, but there is a legitimate question about the 6/7/72
, process. Approve
I
i .,. ,
E. Liquor Li cense Appl.j.cations
1. Renewals - The following applications for renewal of liquor licenses were
presented and permission asked to release them prior to the formal Council
"meeting, June.l2 to' allow licensees time to .forward them to the Liquor Commis-
! si'Oi1 for .i t's June meeting:
,
: Retail Malt ,Beverage Class A (RMBA) Retail M~lt Beverage Class A (RMBA) ,
'.JLC Sports Concession Stand #1 and Package Store Class B (PB)
II' " " " #2 ' The Corner Tavern, 101; West. 7th.
, 2000 Block of willamette . "
'- - - ~,.
i '., Package. Store Class A, (PA)
i Retai,l Malt Beverage Class- C (RMBC). Becraf.t & Nason Market, lOBS West 4th
, Brass Rai.l, 746',.West Park .' ~. . ~
. -The Keg Tavern, 4711 West 11th Package Store Class B (PB)
I Andy's Food MaTket, -304 East 13th
I Restaurant B (RE) _d Edelweiss-Stein, 34 East 10th,
- The Bavarian, 444 East 3rd W~llakenzie Super Market, 1645 Coburg Road
,
I _n COmIn
Class, A;:.nispensers (DA) , . ,- Class-'B_'Dispensers (DB) 6/7/72
I Ford's Restaurant, 1769 Frankl-in.Blvd . Club Crosstown, J.7.97 Wei/t' 7tfi
! ' Fob's, .764 Willamette Approve
!
.~. - - . . ...) ~ -- - -' ' -. , .. Ron- and .Maddy' s Caravel'le, 160 South Park
i .<
i l1r. Mohr moved seconded by -Mr. Williams to recomrn'end approval of the . appll ca-
,-
j tions. -Motion carried unanimouSl'i L:, gJ ~" .
6(15/72 - 3
r
F. Liquor License Application - Grogg Shop, 1677 Coburg Road'- This application
(RMBC), submitted by Robert C. Beckley, was recommended for approv~l at the
May 31, 1972 Council meeting wi thout attention being called to the number of
objections to its issuance in the neighborhood (13 out of 18 questioned by the
local OLCC people). Manager suggested reconsideration of the application at the Comm
June 12 Council meeting to allow objections to be heard. It was' understood the 6/7/72 .
application will be listed on_the June 12 agenda. Approve
G. Civic Center Design Plan (Planning ,Comndssion May 22/23, 1972) - Council was
asked to adopt a resolution, copies of _which were previously distributed, endors-
ing the concept of the December 1971 civic center design plan and indicating its
willingness to be represented on an ad hoc co-ordinating comnd ttee made up of two
members from ,each participating agency - Federal government, state of Oregon, Lane
County, ci ty of Eugene, and the Eugene Water & Electri c Board. The Planning'Com-
mission recommended approval of the _plan, with the stipulation that the Commission
is concerned about the recommendations and goals of the design plan as they
relate to traffic in that they are in conflict with the transportation element of
the.1990 General Plan; approval should in no way admit to ratification of the
Skinner.' s Butte Freeway nor in -any _way approve a vehicular-,:oriented civic center
design plan. The Commission would like to_proceed with deliberations on the make-
up of the ad hoc committee, its goals and charges, which should be subject to fur-
ther consideration before the committee begins its work. I
Manager explained that official recognition of the_ design plan is needed at this
time to protect the plaza concept - separation_of vehicles and pedestrians, 'inte-
gration of mass transit, pedestrian access between the center and Skinner's Butte,
and potential for joint agreements on maintenance and operation of the common- .
area. The Federal government is proceeding wi th plans for' construction of its
building on 7th between Pearl and High, the Water Board and the State will be con-
structing buildings soon, and all agencies involved have agreed-there is no reason
why any future construction should not be compatible with the proposed civic center I
design plan. I
Adoption of this resolution will be considered by each of the agencies, and there
is nothing in its adoption which will preclude actin on those things -about which
there is still concern, but indicates a desire to proceed on a joint intergovern-
mental, program. The study upon which the design plan is based concludes that the
concept of governmental agencies at this location and in a, center of this size is
acceptable. Staff people of the various agencies feel to proceed in this direction
is proper and so recommend.
Mrs. Campbell noted the statement in the plan that Skinner's Butte freeway will
be constructed, incl uding a - connection wi th the central distri ct and proposed
transportation center, and that the Civic _Center design plan is. predicated on a
number of important. changes to existing streets whi ch 'will be the Ci ty , s problem.
Manager said the concern of the design people at this poizt in time is the traffic
movement need which would be served by the Skinner's Butte freeway. 'Without some
other faci1i ty or some other decision made there will be- congestion. Acceptance -:
of this design does not . prec1ude other answers _ to that prob1em~rlOr' does endorse-
_J'
ment constitute endorsement.of the Skinner's Butte freeway.
Councilman Bradshaw said it seems that acceptance of this integrated concept would
mean acceptance of those problems, if not Skinner's Butte freeway, then something
else.
Mrs. Bea1 expressed concern about lack of overall planning, about segmentation of
the planning group, and the effect that construction of the center will have on
other areas. She noted discussion in process concerning creation of a group con-
cerned primarily with downtown parking and wondered how so many different bodies
can bring the planning into an integrated whole. Planning Director commented on
the Commission's concern with this issue and its feeling that the plaza concept
for certain administrative functions of government is excellent and needs to be
in the central area. He said there are so many unknowns it is difficult to make
decisions affecting transportation problems in the future, but in making recommenda-
tions for approval of the plan the Commission wanted to make the Council aware
of obvious conflicts. Mrs. Bea1 remarked that it would seem better to have full-
time staff people to-work on the solution to these problems rather than creating
more committees and further segmenting the planning.
Manager said it is recognized the point will necer be reached where everything is -
planned and accepted by the entire community before construction is started. How-
ever, at this time the Federal government is proceeding wi th abuilding, EWEB has
purchased the property for their building in the center, andthe County is accumulating
a building fund, so that it seems the agencies are more nearly integrated in their
planning work to this point than is normal in these situations. He reviewed initia-
"- -~ "
l I/QCJ 6115/72 - 4
\
tion of the study on which the plan is based, including transportation ~tudi~s
and planning, and said there is still going to be a problem .faced in moving tra;ffic
unless some facility is provided for that movement. Endorsement of this concept
seems to.be the best way at this time to bring about an integrated approach to
the problem.
. Councilman Bradshaw said the public will be asking why the County building~ and
the auditorium are .not located on the Belt Line or in those areas where there is
existing transportation, and he suggested the -Council should be prepared to answer
these questions. . 'Manager said joint utilization of space is one consideration.
Mr. Bradshaw asked if new State construction will be balanced by that, or mass
transit construction. Mayor Anderson said there is also the commitment to revitalize
the downtown. area.; . work is in progress to change .the character of downtown to combine
professional, retail, financial, and government functions. Any change at.this point
would not only prove costly but would. perhaps tend to compound errors already made.
Councilman Williams asked if the planners wouldstill.be of the opinion that this
center should be built should the Skinner's Butte freeway or some other facility
not be permitted. Manager said he doesn't think there is an ans~er at this point,
that he feels the planners assume that a solution will.be found which will be ac-
ceptable. He said he doubts that agencies with plans to locate buildings in, the
proposed design plan area will abandon those plans at this stage. Mr. Williams com-
mented that the only real queston then is, planned or unplanned; whether there will
be congestion or something done to handle th~t congestion. Planning-Director
said he feels there will be congestion no matter where any central administrative
. area for government is located and_ there are various alternative ways of handling
the problem so far as . governmental employes are concerned - work shifts, poo.ling;
etc. - that can't be done with the private sector.
Manager confirmed Mr. Teague's comment th~t endorsement;: of the design plan con-
stitutes recognition of the problems but at this time the Council isno~ saying
how they will be handled.
Mayor Anderson commented that as a governmental.body it may l?e necessary ~t some
time to define "congestion" since things seem to be going in the direction of con-
centration of activity in the downtown area and this will have to ~e accepte~ as a
trade~off for what is wanted in the outlying a~eas.
Councilman Mohr said he thinks one problem to be faced is that this report comes
without benefit of public hearing and a thorough understanding of what is proposed.
Mrs. Beal asked whether it would be a matter of public hearing, or an item for
I approval on the consent calendar.
Mayor Anderson said he doesn't fwel the resolution demands a public hearing, that
I
it merely sets policy this Council will use in making decisions in the future with
respect to the civic center. He said every item before the Council is open to
public comment, but if the Council wants a full-blovyn public hearing he feels it
. would lead to some real " tunnels ," particularly various things which would be brought
in supplementary to the discussion. It amounts to accepting some decisions made by
other people in the past and is really reserving the right to comment and evaluate
certain condi tions that might develop in the future.
I Mrs. Beal moved seconded by Mr. Teague to adopt the resolution approving the
Civic Center Design Plan, with stipulations recommended by the Planning Commission.
Mrs. Campbell asked about the procedure for the recommended street vacations, if
the downtown merchants are aware of that and,-whether it will involve them. Manager
said each street vacation will go through the normal public hearing procedure.
At this time the plan is generally. schematic and when different elements are put
together each part will have to be considered at. that time. 'He said there is no
answer as to whether any specific street closure will be acceptable.
Mrs. Beal said it is probably acJmowledged that nothing can be done about plans of
the Federal government with regard to their building and co-ordination with other
buil dings. Manager said every encouragement has been given to. the Federal people
by this body, the County, and others invol ved in the ci vi c center concept to use
that location.
.. Councilman Bradshaw noted that his comments were npt in opposition to the design
plan or concept, but that he was trying to assess trade-offs. Comm
6/7/72
Vote was taken on the motion as stated, and_ motiop carried unanimously. Approve
H. Vacation, Center Way 493 feet more or less south of Martin Street (Brant Enter-
prises) - Planning Commission May 22/23, 1972 recommended approval. Public Works
Director said the street was surveyed before the property was subdivided. This
/70 6/15/72 - 5
vacatian will becam~ effective simultaneaus1y 'with filing .of plat far subdivisian
. . - .' -. ,. - . , . . ~ ' -. - . I . . . .. , 1 . . r .
which 'prQvides iQI_ded.i"cat;ion, .of Cil :new st~eet,. . _ '
:, .." . _',.. -, -: ' " ' " _, _: ~.. '. ': " . '.. _ _ c' ,,_ _ c " Camm
Mr. Mohr moved secandedby Mrs. Bea1 'ta'cal1 a pub1i'dhearing oil 'the 'propased 6/7/72 _
vacatian. Matian carried unanimausly. Approve .
I ~;~~nne~~tian, .r~arih~ast' car~~-r B~l t '.Li/l~ and Ri;;er R;~d (Fied Mey~r, ':-lilc.) - e,
, Plaim,~ng Cariiii!ii?sJori'May ??'/23,- )972 -reerainIneriif.ed appraval 'sUbject ,ta (a) develap-
ment 'taking pLace'under p1amuid unit develapment pracedtil-e; ~d (bi ;m1?e~atian
'. , I '. . -,- . '.., ' .
nat being_ finalized until after the .improvemel].f; iti Cil9ded t;q" 'the tax .rap. ,Manager
natE!d ~hat 'tJ;lis is ,the first;' ,prapasi#~ _~o ex~e4d .t;He City _lirilitsno,r,t,h a~ ,!:he B.elt
Line 'west -.oF the -Willamette 1?i vex. . -He--said - the-PUD - pra'Cedure is acceptable' ta
, \'" ... '. .' . . . .' ~
the pet;i,tianer and, that the. City, can:-"p:pavide ser'~r servise 1:=.0 the; _praperty ,by
farce Il!ain, tyi,ng inta the. _ trl,1Ilk in, the .D,aneba ,CilrE?a, ,vyi t,hQl;lt, further. investment.
,'" ,,' " - - -, .,: -. ..' ',,' -' - Camm
Mr. Mahr moved,secandE!d by Mr. Br.adshaw ta ,schedule the anne~atian_pe~itian 6/7/72
far public hearing.. ,Mo.~,ion carried l:1nanimauslii. Approve
~. - -..!
J. . ImpravementP~titians,.: ,_ _ _,. 'p" ".
..i. Sanitary sewer'tdserv~ industriallats,.petween West 1st, and West 6th-,=".?6%
2. Paving jeppesel]..5--A"ve1?ue~~tween Ne.wford P"-iz=rk and Gaadpasture Parlf, and'~---
san)tary seweffi"t.o servJ' eas.~ half ef Lat 4201 - 100% .," _ _'~ .'
3. Sani-cary se~er ,?n River Raad- -f:r;om- Cj:Qi!2S, Street 1000 feet north - 45%. :,,_'
4. Paving, san) tarl) aIl4 starm sefier wi thin Brewer Park - 100% ., '
5. " , " . .~' --:-_':' "."i ; 1st Additiap'tQr:S6u-thridge ,- 100%
. ,) ... . "~ ;7' ... -~ ~ . -.. ..........,
6." " _._? ".,_,~!-'--3-,ahdj::>edestrian ways'Within'Somerset Hills..,.93% .--
7._ Sani tary sewerbet;"ee;~u;s-:i9 anij 40g::teet ~e;t and b~J~e;n 5th and 1700 feet ~ '
narthwest - 16% ~- ~ --
~ /', ? .
Manager sai d' the County Sani tarian ' s offi ce has advised of need -for sewer inc., the
are,,! petitianed by owners .of only 16% orthe propertyta be assessed west-;f
99N and northwest .of 5th Avenue. Public Warks Directar said a 50% petitian is
nat pecess~ry,for sew~r.installatian"and suggested, taking t~e,p~titian ta public
hearing in award .of bids ~a _'deterinine ~y abjectians. -
. ." .,".. . . I ~ ' .
.-. . ~_ ~ _ "_: : t
Cauncilman Williams questianed the 45% petitiap far, sewer .on Rive;r Ra9,~ fram:"
, Crass Street narth. Public Warks Director said this is ta serve an area rece'ntly
annexed., As ,_C1 st~pulatioI}- aE th~t _ anI}-(i;xati9n thepraperty owner agreed ta, pay
the entire cost .of tJ;1e,se_wer,~wl}ich.~ill be brallghtaut in public hearing an the
bid aWC1rds.
Carom
Mr. Hershner moved secanded by Mr. Mahr ta accept the pebtdians. Matian carried 6/7/72
unanimausly , Apprave
. .. . " . "- , . . r I
K. Segregation of Assessment, Henry Schaltan ~ Request ta segregate $478.76 .of the
sewer assessment against praperty at 8~9 C:r;est Drive, leaving a palance .of
$502.51. Payment. for the_partdian segreg~ted has been_received.
- .. ,,' - '- -, ',' -
Camm.,
Mr. Hershn~;r mov.ec] ,secanded by Mr. Mohr ta_ apprave the segregatian. Mati an 6/7/72' ,.~
carried unanimausly. Apprave
L. Liaisan with Auditarium Assaciatian - Mayar Ander{3on. appain'f;ed Mrs. Ci!fInpbell Carom
tq, wark wj,th the Audi.tarj..um Assaciati.on in preparatian .of final plans far 5/31/72
the auditarium/canventian center. Affirm
,
M. Amazan Village Cammunity Center,' Progress Repart - ?a;rks Dir,ecta;r_ Point,ed aut
lacatian and plat plan .of three buildings ta be knawn as the _ Ama~an 'Village I
Cammuni ty Center flIld la,crated sauth ,aftJ;le Amazan Park swimming paal and play-
graund area~- He--explaJ.ned.the-'cancept ,as- a s~rie,s .of three-buil,dings, with the
passibility .of adding athe:r; buildings in the. fU,ture ,an(1, par~ing area develaped
ta allow eventual removal .of parking'fram Hilyard Street. '
-. -
Don Lutes, .of Lutes & Amundsan, architects and; designers .of, the prajept, d,?scr,ibed
b~ildings, sC1ying thE! deve1apment is smaller ip. s,ize thap .originally cancei ved ,
because financing did nat, become availabletllraugh HUD funds and is being accam-
p1ished with' City funds.-' The three buildings p~avidemeeting roams, .office
space, arts and crafts space, yauth center, with cannecting covered walkways.
He saii! the centl$r, has expansian capability" each unit [flay be .operated, independently ~
withaut having ta staff the entire, cl$n,ter, and avoid~ canflict _ between age graups_
at a tatal cast .of abaut $263,000. Parking and landscaping will be dane by City
farces auts;ide tha~ amaunt. Each building cantains 2400 ta 2~00 square feet ata
cast .of abaut $60,000 each. It is anticipated bids an the project will be called
in late July, with .occupancy expected early_ next summer, and staffing provided
in the next year's budget.
I 7/ 6/15/72 - 6
Couilcilinan Teague questioned the cost quoted (figured at about $24 per square
foot) . Mr. Lutes said that compares to present-day costs for a building con-
structed in a manner consistent with keeping maintenance cost at a minimum.
He said over the last 16 years construction costs have gone from less than
. $10 to more than $22 per square foot.
Mrs. Campbell inquired abOut the location of the center in relation to the Amazon
swimming pool. Parks Director said activity areas were taken into 'consideration
in locating the center, also development of parking area to avoid further con-
gestion. Mrs. Campbell asked whe.ther an ice skating rink is included in future
plans. Parks Director replied that that type of recreational facility is regional
in nature and would be more suitably located in Alton Baker Park, utilizing park-
ing in existence around Autzen Stadium.
Mr. Williams also expressed curiosity about the construction cost and asked
whether sketches of the inside of the buildings are available. Mr. Lutes offered
to send him enlarged~p1ans which he said would give a good idea of the inside.
Parks Director commented on the rise in mechanical and labor costs and the tre-
mendous increase in costs on other centers recently developed. He said alterna-
tives have been built into this plan to get as much as possible for the money
spent.
Councilman Mohr noted that the plan presented reflects the opinions expressed
in a community attitude survey on needs to be met in a community center. He
said it is important to recognize the emphasis on the concept of providing centers
. on a smaller scale and for activities other than strictly athletic, which has been
stressed in planning community centers in the past.
In answer to Mrs. Campbell, Mr. Lutes said the costs quoted do not include fur~
nishings, only basi c construction and some. site improvement.. Parks Director
said it is planned to split funds in the department's operating budget to buy
sufficient equipment to get the center started. Mrs. Campbell ascertained from
Mr. Lutes also that kitchen facilities will be included to serve the meeting
room, with capability of serving other areas because of the .covered walkways....
-,
Michael Sprague, -23l-East 12th Avenue, suggested dome construction at about half
or one-fourth normal cost for comparable internal volume of space. Mr. Lutes
said dome construction, although more efficient for covering a large area, would
not be acceptable for this concept of creating small spaces segregated to avoid
noise and confli ct of programs and. acti vi ties. - He sai d his firm's experiences
with that type of construction is that although the structural cost is inex-
I pensive, the other parts - mechanical systems, partitions, proper installation
of doors and windows because of invol vement wi th angles and- slopes - increase
I the overall cost rapidly and make it more. than the conventional box-type)
construction.
Mr. Sprague suggested that feasibility of dome construction be explored to give
. the community an experience. It is the type of building the younger people
like, he said, and would be a good experiment to determine how people relate
-" and how -the. Ci ty. dre!?ponds to it.. He said'it would be consistent with Eugene's
goals of-becoming known as a somewhat Unusual and experimental City_.
I Comm
The Consensus of the Council was that the concept had been approved previously 6/7/72
and this was a progress report on implementation of that concept. Affirm
N. Results of Ballot Measures, May 23 Primary - Mayor Anderson commented on the
defeat of the l~% County income tax and auto license fee increase ballot measures,
saying further steps will probably have to come through the Governor's T.ask Force
on School -Financing. He expressed concern that there is still nothing in sight
for tax-reform involving local government finances. and. said the proper.ty' tax Comm
seems to be the only route unless the Congress enacts legislation ini.tiating a 5/24/72
sizeable revenue sharing program. File
O. Lane 'Arts Festival Plans for June 29 to July 9,.-Dlympic Trials - Mrs. Hope
Pressman, working on co-ordination of cultural activities in Eugene during the
Olympic Trials period from June 29 to July 9 this year, presented Council members
with .copies of theschedu1e'of events. She briefly -described what will take
place in the way of special exhibitions and events as apart of the cOntinuing
. exhibitions and programs, and public programs,. and participants. She said they
are concerned primarily wi th filling the hours arouna. the. -trails' events; i. e. , -
prior to-1'.:00 p.m. andfrom 7:00 p.m. on. . Mayor Anderson' expressed.appreciation
for th~ splendid program designed to augment the track and field events.
Mrs. Campbell also thanked Mrs. Pressman for the program which demonstrates a
great deal of time and effort spent by many people who perhaps have never had
- - ':":~
-
/7:J 6/15/72 - 7
"
the chance before to participate in City affairs. In answer to Manager, Mrs .'Press- Comm
man said ther.e i:s State-wide Ciistribution of knowledge abou,t the e1(e!2ts through 5/24/72
Paul Lansdowne's group, the Chamber of Commerce, 'and the 'AJ;ts Commission. File
P. City Council TV Show - Michael Sprague, candidate for Congressman from District IV, -
asked the Council to take action to have its meetings taped or broadcast live .
on television.. He said the Coqncil then would not have to have 'personal contact
~,
wi th the communi ty i'n order for the community to 'become aware of decisions made'
in its -behalf~ He said he talked 'to Teleprompter people about the pJ;oposal and
that h~ feels they_ should move ahead with encollrage]1len_t _from the Council since ,they
were giyen a rate incr_ease_.
In reply to Mr. Sprague, Manager said there is no mention_ in Teleprornpter_' s fran-,
chise from the City that they broadcast City activities. Councilman Mohr noted
that in its presentation to the_Council two years ago for a rate increase'Tele-
prompter stated the Cable Company had autpprity_.to proad9d$t a City Co_unci,l s_how
and vol unteered one of_ 'their empty channels.
/ .
Mr. Sprarjue asked~the Council to adopti;he p:(oposal and _recqmmend that Council
meetings be broadcast over cable televi$ion, and that Teleprompter be requ.ested
to make this a reality. He said it would give an opportunity for the community
to see what happens before elections this fall. He cited media action in the
city of .Coburg and the part it plays in bringing about community involvement
wi th the Council in that city.
Mayor Anderson said he felt the Council would resppnd affipnatively, to such pro-
gramming, but from the standp<i>i!nt of :freedom involved in_ di$s_emination of informa- .
tion he does not think the Council would want to place itself in" a position
-<
politically to force its will on media such as Teleprompter. If it could be done
outside official action by the Council, it would be 'good and he 'would encourage it.
He suggested that Mr. Sprague propo$e a program 'to Tceleprompter.
Mr. Sprague said he feels that i,f Council members do not adopt a program of this
nature they are reneging on their responsibility to communicate in as many
ways as possible to those who voted them into office. He aSked the Council to
request television coverage the same as it asks _ for press coverage.
Members of the press present immediately'respDnded that they were not requested ,to
be at any of the Council meetings. Pa~l Richards of KEZI'TV sai,p there are very
strict FCC regulations ,governing dissemination of puhl_ic information .and that it
is not encumbent upon government to undertake a posi ti ve informat.i,on program through
thepuhlic airways.
-- -. - . -
Mayor Anderson again said that if the media asked to televise . Council meetings, he I
thinks the Council would be receptive to the idea. Mr. Sprague said he feels it
would be a mistake politically not to do it. He said Teleprompter has said they
cannot afford to do it.
.', - - ,.
Councilman, Mohr said there-is no question but that all of t~e media know they are
welcome to cover any of the Council meetings, but in view of the results of the -"'.c.'
primary election (ballot issues affect.ing City _finances) he doubted' the, effective-
ness of such coverage. He said Council will not provide funds to sponsor them-
selves on television.
Mayor Anderson left ~the committee meeting and Council President Mohr
assumed the chair.
Mrs. Campbell expressed the opinion that ratings on such a show would be low and
asked if it wOilld be the intent to edit lengthy meetings to cut alt much of the
routine action. Mr. Sprague said there would be someediting,.but,that would
delay broadcast.
Councilman Bradshaw said he thinks such a proposal would result in a mass of Comm
political speeches and. that the public is subjected to enough pressure now. He 5/24/72
said he opposes the idea. No' action was taken. -, - File
Q. Spencer's Butte Improvement Association - Letter received from the Association,
copies' of which were distributed previously to Council members, requested recog-
nition and, involvement in the planning process of the South Eugene area. Manager .'
said there would be concern with rega~d to a.;;surq.nqe that the- people who presume
to be representing a neighborhood ~d hav~ng that responsibility do so without
being elected. He said there would be no p:(oblem of involviIlg this' group with the
planning process in an advisory nature similar to the group in the Laurelhi11 area.
_. ...... ~-"-=~ - --: -::-......~ ;; ~~!!: ., .~. .- -P
-
--.;:'"--".:" --'~ ,.~[::-~. ~ ~~-.
" ~ -
---
/73 6/15/72 -" 8 -
Mrs. Campbell asked whether they are asking for ,representation on the Planning
Commission, and Manager replied they are asking to serve on any commission,
committee, or advisory group in existence making planning decisions in the South
Eugene region.
. Mrs. Campbell asked whether LCOG should consider the request since the people in
the Association live outside the City limits. Manager said it is not necessary
that all Planning Commission members live within the City; however, there are no
vacancies on the Commission, which is established by State law. If the group
is recogni zed as part of, the commission it woul d have to be on an advisory com-
mittee basis. .
Public Works Director reported that the Planning Commission at its May 23 meeting
received the same_letter from the Association and concluded they could not be
recogni zed as, a body because they are not wi th1.n the Ci ty . However, a _ formal
letter will be written welcoming them to participate as members of the community.
A report on the request will be coming to the Council from the Commission.
Mrs. Campbell commented that some of the people of the Spencer's Butte Improve-
ment Association appear regularly at City meetings, and they are particul<;J.rly
concerned with the South Eugene area and interim density plan for that area now
under discussion.
..
Further discussion took place on procedure to include the Spencer's Butte people Comm
in the structural organization and whether they had representation on the Com- 5/24/72
munity Goals Committee. No action was taken. File
. R. City Hall Parking ~ Manager explained that under th~ present method of renting
parking space to City employes ($7.50 per month and established when City Hall
opened) the pa!king area wi)l be subject to property tax. If that area is put
on the tax rolls it would mean an increase of $5.00 per month to employes. Also,
there is not enough parking now to accommodate the public and City vehicles.
Manager said he feels priority should go first to City cars; second, to the
public; and third, to City employes.
An arrangement is being developed with the Eugene Water & El~ctric Board for
the half-block now being cleared across 8th from the City Hall, and with the
Baptist Church on the Cfuartez::-block at the southeast corner of 8th and fligh for
rental to Ci ty employes at $ 8,.00 per month. Space so provided will be more than
needed, so it is proposed to install meters on the, west end of the EWEB half-
boock for daily and/or monthly parking at a higher rate for others than City
I employes. Spaces cannot be assigned, parking will be by permit on a first-come,
first-served basis to avoid individual rental which would bring the property onto
I the tax rolls. Manager said this arrangement is_ temporary since eventual,ly EWEB
plans to build on that site. He said the proposal has been discussed briefly with
the Employes Association and with union leaders so that they_ are aware, of the
change, but there has been no feedback yet.
. Mrs. Campbel+ commented that the proposal is consistent with the terms of the
propose,d ordinance creating a Downtown Development Board in that' it is recom-
mended downtown employes buy parking permits rather than use the free parking.
I _ r~ .
Michael Sprague asked if .,there is provision for bicycle parking. Manager
answered there is no proposal to sell bicyc~e parking spaces to City employes Comm
although there are a good many bicycles used and parked at various'locations 5/24/72
around City.Hall.. File
S. Report on Mall Regulations Survey - Manager said a redraft of the mall reg~la-
tions will be mailed to Council members for study prior to receiving the report Comm
on a mall regulations survey prepared by Professor Allman's class. It was de- 5/24/72
cided ,the report would be 'given at next week's committee meeting. File
7;. Appointment, Zoning Board of Appeals - Mayor Anderson asked' CoUncil members for
suggestions not, later than the middle of next week for filling a vacancy on the
Zoning Board of Appe,als . The vacancy occurs as the resul t of the death of Comm
A. W. Krieg, recently reappointed. Mr. Anderson commented on his excellent 5/31/72
work as a member of the Board. File
. u. Complaint, Use of South Kincaid_Ball Field - Mrs. Campbell reported that Ronald
Weiss, 3945 East 'Amazon Drive, is concernedabout'cthe Parks Department policy
of allowing adult males to play baseball at the South Kincaid field. He' has -ex-
perienced broken windows, harassment, basebal~s on the roof and into his -house,
andhas.recovered damages from the City in the past. Mr. Weiss, she said, is
not concerned about chi ldren' s use of the field but that it is too small for
adult use.
/74 6/15/72 - 9
r
Parks Director ~ommented on Mr. Weiss~ tolerance of the situation_which ha~
. ',', ' , ' '-".' I '. .
existed for several years. ,Therule$ on use' of. the field have' been changed~-
the backstop eniarged, and a' higher fence installed, but still the problem'
exists (even wi th playing rules changes to "over the fence is out ~ ") . Director Comm
said it appears rescheduling is necessary; he will report back to tl1e -council 5/31/72 -
" 1 ",' . . ---"'-
on what takes pla.'ce. ' ' . ", - , File .
... . 'J" .,. ,
v. Tour, Ridgeline Area - Mrs. Campbell suggested a 'tour of the Ridgeline area
1 . . . .
prior tocorisideration of the inter;im den$ityplan for that 'area scheduLed for Comm
discussion at' the June 12 meeting. Manager said a t'ourwill be arranged 'prior 5/31/72
to the June 7 comrnrrttee meeting. File
W. Report>Mall use'Study -,This, report is the resuitof'C;; pro'posaipr~sentedby
Professor Allman's class a't the unive;s'ity'that somd 'of'the students-work with
," _' . . " . ,. . , , .' : . . \ ." . . .. ,'. . . I I , . . 1 I ~ ' t:. . '. , \
the Counci,l in providing researc:h input and manpower ,to, review iufd develop sollie
definitive 'statistics on 'us.~'s or the ma~l and'what"'it ~e~~ to people'in the
community. ' ,,' ' 1 1
Councilman Mohr said that he and Councilman, Wiliiams; Beal, 'and Teague l!let '
several - times wi t'h the student' group, to frame di.'rections and set po1'icy guide-
lines for'development of a questionnaire. He said an incredible amount' 'of work was
. -
done by the group in collecting data from a large sampling of business people and
ci tizens.,
'- , .. ~
Rachel Starr, chairman of the student group, said the project was undertaken as
a result of the controversy which developed over use of the mall during'th~ sum~ .
mer of 1971. She reviewed the summary of the results of the questionnaire, and
said the group felt the results would have provided a base for policy recommenda-
tions had questions beEm lncludf3d with regard, to econoIrd.c considerations. They
did not ask questions concernin~, in,come, whetlJ.er people wC?uldbe, willing to pay
for any changes they might favor, address (to determine frequence of trips to
the mall), etc-. ' ' '1' " -, ;
Councilman Mohr commented on the small percentage of response on cuitural use
of the mall compared to response on commercial use in light of the Council's
move to establish policy in that.r~gard.
Ms. Star+" in response to Mrs. BeaJ, sad d those inter,viewed 'represented' ~out 'one-'
third of the membership of the E~geneDowntown Association (42) pl~ 276 citizens.
council~a.n Moh~ sa~d ~hlsqtiestionnalre from 276 -pe6ple int'i:Jis' one city' gives
very solid statistics. , ,
.. " ':' , '" -
Mayor Anderson expre~sed apprec:iation to the'students and ~aid he feels the
counqil i's headi~g in'the right di,rection i'n 'cons'lderation -Of 'mall use!>'. Council- I
man Mohr noted that the student group is 'repr,esentativeof the resources avail- Comm
, , '
able for thie type research and expressed hope that their services will be used 5/31/72
again on other projects. File
x. Amend _tqry Application, Downtown Project - copJes of a memorandum dated May 26, .
1972 from J. Davi dHunt, executi ire ~irector, oX- E,ugene Renewal AgEmcy, 'gi ving ,
analysis of amendatory application for Federal funds, were"di'srributed to' Caunci1
members by Theron Rust. (Manager announced Mr. Rust's resignation as Assistant
ERA DireCtor to accept a posi tion as Urban. Ren.ewa1 Director in Tempe, Arizona.)
Mr. Hunt distributed copies of the Agency's budget and explained the Agency will
be inva1ved in reviewing the Central Eugene project to determine the leve,l of
funding which can be acquired and then finance accordingly. He said there will
be no change in the planning. He :r;eviewed in detail the various project expendi- I
ture~ involved ne:cess,itatLng ,a request' far additional' fUnds in the amauntof
$7.4 million r and the project cost estimate and financin,r;; plan., Two fac~ors he
noted of importance in, the application are inclusion qf parking garages and
the auditorium. -Mr. Hunt said there are no specifics with regardfo' the garage
structures a~, thi~ time, but a con~u1tant will, be retained to determine sizes,
number of, spaces, and 1acations fa;r 1Cfter Caunci1 review. He said the auditarium
is included because the application must be submitted 'now; it' cannot wait for
outcome of the'Navember voting, and:HuD will not a1lqw its~inc1usian ata later
date should the project be approved.
Councilman Mahr said an several occasians the Caunci1 has been cantacted with
regard, to price of properties in the downtown area, co.f!iments 'being made that' .
ERA has sold propert'ies at _a lower 'price 'than others.' He asked if the applica-
tioriwill include funds to make up'the difference. Mr. Hunt said 'adjustments have
. ..' t .'., ..'
been necessary because of the 10th and Oak assessments and failure af the structure
to come up ta,projected,revenues, and because of theconte~p1ated free parking
district and hesitancy of people to purchase for fear of'having to carry the
assessment in an enlarged district. He said it is a changing si tuatian and
/75 6(15/72 - 10
\
difficult to have stabilized land values, bl.!-t that the Agency is trying to gain
the maximum dollars out of the land and still -seli the property.' Mr. Hunt fur-
ther explained differences between Agency. and private buying and selling of
properties, this in answer to Mr. Mohr's comment that a report prepared by Dean
Lindholm of the Uni versi ty fO.und that the downtoWn area is overassessed when
e compared to shopping centers.
Councilman Williams asked whether funds would h~ve to be furnished locally if
the non-cash credit were not included for the auditorium, and whether ERA or
City funds are committed if the voters do approve the auditorium bond issue.
Mr. Hunt replied that if the non-cash credit were not included, and if the voters
approve - the l?ond issue, a cash amount will have to be provided; if it is included
then the .credi t will be. available and if it is not used will be available for
some future time.
Mrs. Campbell asked if, the Council.could' play a re~enforcing roJe - making state- Comm
ments, arguments, etc. ..Mr. ,Hunt saidthe.Agency will_ be involved in discussions 5/31/72
with the Federal people and will be asking support. He said the timing of the File
application is af importance because by the end of this year the Agency's financial
pasition will be ,tight with more than $4 million in contracts in the project
scheduled during the next year.
Y. DEQ.Meeting re: Noise Pollution -' Mrs. Beal called,:,._ttention to a meeting of
the Department af Environmental Quali ty scheduled in the, Co.uncil Chamber this - Camm
evening (6/7/72) to discuss naise pallutian. Mrs. Campbell volunteered to at~, 6/7/72
tend as a Cauncil member. File
. z. 911 Emergency_ Telephone Number - Councilman Williains asked if there is some way
of initiating. establishment of -the-.9ll. emergency telephoile..numb,er in this area.
Assistant Manager replied that',wark has been in progress' for. over a year but be-
cause af each agency's. hesitancy to give',up Its awn dispatching duties-it has",
nat been passible to. co-ardinate to. the paint_-af agreement., He said efforts
are continuing toward that end. In answer to Mrs. Beal, he said at the present
time the telephone company still offers its assistance, dial the aperator and
ask for assistance.
Comm
Manager said the City will be, gaing to. "Centrex" system this year sa there will 6/7/72
be. different numbers for each of the major City offices. , File
- ';- - J :'-- : '
AA. Recertification, Workable Program - Manager announced receipt of recertifica-
tion af Eugene's Warkable pragram through May 31, 1974. He explained the pur- Comm
I po. se of the Program and need for its recertification in carrying out urban renewal, 6/7/72
housing, neighborhood development, etc., programs in th~ City. File
I BB. Speed, Goodpasture Island Road - State Speed Control Board notified the City
of its praposal to retain the existing speed zone (40 mph) on Gaodpasture
Island Raad between Norkenzie Road and Delta Highway. Official actian will be Carom
. taken at the next meeting af the Baard; any Objections must b,e received within 6/7/72
30 days. File
, ,
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal to approve, affirm, and file as noted Items A through BB
I Rol~c~ll vote. Motion carried, all councilmen present voting aye, except Mr. McDonald 'ab-
stalnlng.
II - ITEMS NOT PREVIOUSLY DISCUSSED
A.Request for Bid Waiver - Paving, sanitary and storm sewers in Brewer Park. Work will
be contracted to Devereaux &, Pratt for $2,.913.77 with Charles O. Ogle paying the
'entire cost.
Mr. Mohr moved s_econded by Mrs. Beal to approve the. bid waiver.
Rollcall vote. All - councilmen: present ,voting aye, mqtion carried.
B. Liquor License Applications
New - RMBC - Grogg Shop, 1677 Coburg Road ,- Robert C. Beckley
Ri viera Tavern, 99 River Avenue - J:ohn Langan
Shamrock Hof Brau, 2702 Wilmakenzie - Zeldie and Norine Hawthorne
PB - Dari Mart Store #9, 28th and Friendly - Gibson &, Gibson
4It Greater Privilege - Requesting Restaurant (A) - Formerly RMBA
Abby's Pizza Inn, 1970 River Road - Edgar and Janice Brown
Greater Privilege and Renewal - B.equesting RMBC - Formerly RMBA and PB _
Machine Gun Alley (formerly Pastime Tavern),
730 Wil~amette - Marion and Genevieve Nixon
'\ / 7 (P 6/15/72 - 11
Change of Ownership - DB - Black Angus, 2123 Franklin Boulevard
Saga Enterprises, Inc., - Formerly Anderson's Black Angus
Renewa~ -- PB - Miller's Grocery, 1065 East 20th Avenue -
DB - Black Angus Restaurant, 2123 Franklin Boulevard .
Warren 'sRestaurant, 652 East Broadway
DCA (less than 500 members) -, ,Columbus Club, 1144 Charnelton
Manager reviewed OLCC report showing objections of neighbors in the vicinity of the
proposed Grogg Shop at-1677 Coburg Road and the- proposed Riviera Tavern at 99 River
Avenue. Other than contact made by the OLCC in its investigation, staff does not know
whether the objectors were aware the applications would be before the Council-_at this
meeting. Mayor Anderson suggested a public hearing to provide opportunity for both
the applicant and obj ectorsto express themselves. Manager noted there .was no reas.on
to recommend denial from, the standpoint, of fire, traffic, _building,', or police depart-
ments. OLCC ,under the-- new procedurEZ, was to inform people questioned on the' applica-
tion of the hearing date. It was originally scheduled for May 22, 1972 but 'the OLCC
reports were not completed at that time.
Councilman Bradshaw wondered what purpos,e a public !J.earing w01lld serve if the staff
has no reason to object and the' location does~not conflict with the zoning ,ordinance.
MCiyor Anderson said any -liquor license application for a newly establishe'd business
~PE~iqat~on~should receive close scrutiny of the Council as well as opinions of people
in the neighborhood. Councilman McDonald wondered about the policy for objections, .'
whether those objecting are business people, property owners, or residents of the area,
- -
and asked whether-the P.olice have given a favorable recommendation on the Grogg Shop's ,"
application. Mayor Anderson reviewed past and present procedures- for handling these
applications, and noted that all applications - new, renewal, change of ownership,
greater privilege - are reviewed by the police department.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal to recommend approval of all applica-
tions listed, except that of the Grogg Shop and the Riviera Tavern. Motion
carried unanimously.
It was understood public hearing woul'd be held at the June 26, 1972 Gouncil meeting and
that those listed as having been interviewed by the OLCC would be~notified of the hear-
ing date.
III - ORDINANCES
Council Bill No. 9711 - Creation of Downtown Development Board, was submitted for first read-
ing by council bill number and title only, there being no councilman present requesting it be I
read in full. ~ .. .
Councilman Mohr felt kudos should be gl~ennthe'subcommittee (Councilmen Te~gue~'Be~l, and Hersh-
ner) which developed the ordinance establishing the Downtown Deveiopment Board. He said it .
broadened the scope and brought public interest in its makeup. Councilman Teague said there was
a good exchange of information a:nd ideas in the committee's meeting with members of the Downtown
Associat ion.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be read the second time by council bill number
only, with unanimous consent of the Council, and that enactment be considered at this time.
Motion carried unanimously and the bill was read the second time by council billlnumber only.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approved and given final passage., Rollcall I
vote. All councilmen present voting aye, the bill was declared passed and numbered 16506.
Council Bill No. :9712 - Calling hearing July 24,1972 re: Vac~-tion Center Way 493 feet more
or less south of Martin Street (Brant Enterprises), was subffiittedand read the first time by
council bill number and title only, there being no councilman present reques~ingit be read in full.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bili be read ~he second time by council bill number
only, with unanimous consent of the Council, and that enactment be considered at this time.
Motion carried unanimously and the bill was read' the second time by council bill lUmber only.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approved an'd given final passage. Rollcall
vote. All councilmen present voting aye, the bill wasdeclared passed and numbe~ed 16507. --
Council Bill No. 9713' - Paving Jeppesen Avenue between Newford Park Subdivision and Good-
pasture Park" Subdivision, was submitted and read the first time by council bill number and title
only, there be~ng no councilman present requesting that it be read in full.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the b'ili be read the second time by council bill number
only, with. unanimous consent of the Council, and that enactment be considered at this time. Motion
carried unanimously and the-bill was read the second- time by council bill number only.
/77 6(15/72 - 12
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approved and given final passage. Rollcall
vote. All councilmen present voting aye, the bill was declared passed -and numbered 16508.
Council Bill No. 9714 - Adopting plans and specifications for paving Jeppesen Avenue be-
tween Newford Park Subdivision and Goodpasture Park Subdi visiol1 was submitted and read the first
. time by council bill number and title only, there being no councilman present requesting that
it be read in full.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs . Beal that the bill be read the ~ecort4"t~inle: bYi:~~~e~~:_~~lj;;_iJ.u_mber
only, with unanimous consent of the Council, and that enactment be consIdered at~inis~~filne.
Motion carried unanimously and the bill was read the second time by council bill number only.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approved and given final passage. Rollcall
vote. All councilmen present voting aye ~ the bill was declared passed and numbered 16509.
Council Bill Nm. 9715 - Construction of sanitary sewer on Jeppesen Avenue between Newford
Park Subdivision and Goodpasture Park Subdivision to serve east half of Lot 4201, was submitted
and read the first time by council bill number and title only, there being no councilman present
requesting that iT be read in full.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be read the second time by council bill number
only,~ wi th 'u:i1?Dimous consent of the Council, and that enactment be considered at this time.
Motion carried unanimously and the' bill was read the second time by council bill number only.
. '. '. J.'"
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approved and given final passage. Rollcal
vote. All councilmen present voting aye, the bill was declared passed and numbered 16510.
. Council Bill No. 9716 ~ Adopting pilians and specifications'for construction of sanitary
sewer on Jeppesen Avenue between Newford Par~ Subdivis~on and GoodpEture Park Subdivision to
serve east hciilf of IDt 4201, wassubmitted and read the first time by council bill number and
title 'only, there being no coUncilman present requesting that it be read in full.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be read the second time by council bill number
mhly,-~lth unanimous consent of the Council, and that enactment be considered at.this time.
Motion carrie-d'uhariimously and the bill was read the second -time by council bill number only.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approved and given final passage. Rol~call
vote.' All councilmen present voting aye, the bill was declared passed and numbered 16511.
Council Bill No. 9717 - Paving streets within Brewer Park Subdivision was submitted and
read the first time by council bill number and title only, there being no councilman present
I requesting that it be read in full.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be read the second time by council bill number
only, with unanimous consent of the Council, and that enactment be considered at this time.
Motion carried unanimously and the -bill was read the second time by council bill nu~er only. -
. Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approved and given final passage. Rollcall
vote.' All councilmen present voting aye, the bill was declared passed and numbered 16512.
Council Bill No. 9718 - Adopting plans and specifications for paving streets within
I Brewer Park Subdivision was submitted and read the first time by oouncil bill number and title
only,~here being no councilman present requesting that it be r~ad in full.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill b eread the second time by council bill number
only, with unanimous consent of the Council, and that ~nactment be considered at this time.
Motion carried unanimously and the bill was read the second tiine by council J?ill nurril?er only ~
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the biJ.l be appro\\1ed and given final passage. Rollcall
vote. All councilmen present voting aye, the bill was declare~ passed and numbered 16513.
Council Bill No. 9719 - Construction of sanitary and storm sewers within Brewer Park
was submitted and read the first time ID~ council bill number and title only, there being no
council man present requesting it be read in full.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be read the second ti~e by council bill' number
only, with unanimous consent of the Council, and that enactment be considered at this time.
Motion carried unanimously and the bill was read the second time by council bill, number only.
. Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the 'bill be approved and given final passage. Rollcall
vote. All councilmen present voting aye, the bill was declared passed and numbered 16514.
CoUncil Bill No. 9720 - Adopting plans and specifications for construction o'f sanitary
and storm sewers within Brewer Park was submitted and read the first time by council bill number
and title only, there being no counci~~~ ~resent- req~~?tirig t~at it be read in full. - -.
17g
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill b~ read the ,second time by council bill number
only, with unanimous consent 6& the Council, and that enactment be considered at this time.
. Motion carried unanimously and the bill was read the second time by council bill number only.
, i
Mr. Mohr mov:~d seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill.be approved and given final passage. Rollcall -
vote. All councilmen presentvofing aye, the bill was declared passed and numbered 16515. -.'
Council Bill No. 9721 - Paving streets within 1st Addition to Southrigge was submitted
Sand read tqe .fi~st time by council bill number a~d title only, there being no councilman present
--'~~ ,. ,.,. .
requesting that i~ be ,read in full.
Mr. Mohr mo'ved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the 'bill be read the second time by council bill number
only, with unanimous consent of the Council, and that enactment be considered at this time
Motion <;:arried. unanimously and the bill was read the second time by council bill number -ofuly.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by 1'1">8. Beal that the bill peapproved and given final passage. Rollcall
vote. All councilmen p.re~ent voting, aye" the bill was declared passed and numbered 16516.
COullcilBill No. 9722 - Adopting plans and specificatioIE for paving stre.ets within 1st
Addition to Southrdige was submitted and read the first time by council bill number and title
'only, there being no c~uncilman present requesting it be read in full.
'I!.. .; '. .. .
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the blll be read.the second tlme by .councll blll number
only, with unanimous consent of the Council, and that enactment be considered at this time.
Motion carried unanimously,. and the bill was read the second time by council bill number only.
Mr. Mohr mo;ed seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approved and given final passage. Rollcall .
vote. . ,All counc~~men present voting.aye; the bill was declared passed and numbered 16517. I
Council Bill No. 9723 - Construction of sanitary and storm sewers within 1st Addition to
Southridge was submitted and read the first time by council bill number and title only, there
being no councilman present requesting that it be read in full.
Mr. Mohr moved,se<;:onded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be read the second time by council bill number
only, with. unanimous cons~nt of the. Council, and that enactment be considered at this time.
Motion carried unanimously and the bill was read the second time by council bill number only.
Mr. Moqr moved seconded by.Mrs. I
Beal tha:t the bill be approved and given final passage. Rollcall
vot e . All councilmen present voting aye, the bill was declared passed and numbered 16518.
Council Bill No. 9724 - Adopting plans and specifications for construction of sanitary
and storm sewers within 1st Addition to Southridge was submitted and,read the first time by
council bill number and title only, there being no councilman ppesent requesting it be read in ful .
Mr. Mohr moveCise<;:ondedby Mrs.: Beii1 that the bill be read the second time by council bill number I
only, w:i,thunanimous conpep:~ of _-the. CounGil~ and-:that --enactin-errb;;be'-con~j;"-dered-:at this 'tIme:. -;- '
0, f1ot~pji~a~i1:I:tcl~ un~nimQus~~d~<e*b-i;1I*;was :;rea~r the se'cohdtime' by council bril-rfumber0)Iily -.-
~'" __.:-_"'=.~...::"\""'''' :;--"_"-"'.:0_ .~-.-' "j:.-. _~....::; ;,.~~.:~_~_ ~:_::-_'-'---.r..-"::"" -."..- .
Mr. Mo~r mqved ,seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approved. and given final, passage. Rollcall
vote. All councilmen present voting aye, the bill was declared passed and numbered 16519.
, Council Bill No. 9725 -:-'Paving streets within :Somerset Hills Subdivision and 160 feet
adj acent to said sUbdi vislon, was suJ:)mitted and read the first time by <ouncil bill number ,and
title only, there being no councilman present requesting it be read in full.
I
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be read the second time by council bill number
,~phly~1w~th~Ufu~imous cQnsent of the Council, and that enactment be considered at this time.
~~-~~--~-' I
Motion carried unanimously and the bill was read the second time by council bill nuWher only.
Mr. Mohr moved seo;nded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be' approved and given final passage. Rollcall
vote. All councilmen present voting aye, the bill was declared passed and numbered 16520.
Co~cil_Bill No. 9726 - Adoptping plans and specifications for paving streets within
Somerset Hills Subdivision and 160 feet adjacent to said subdivision, was submitted and read the
first time by council bill number and title only, there being no councilman present requesting
that it be read in f~ll.
Mr. Mo~r moved. seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be read the second time by council bill number
only, with unanimous consent of the Council, and that enactment be considered at this time. .
Motion carried unanimously and the bill was read the second time by council bill number only.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approved and givEn final passage. Rollcall
vote. All councilmen present voting aye, the bill was deClared passed and numbered 16521.
. . ... 1. . ' .
Council Bill No. 9727 - Construction of sanitary sewer a~d storm sewer within Somerset
Hills and l60 feet adjacent to said subdivision, was submitted and read the first time by council
bill number and t:i..tle only, there being no councilman present requesting it be read in full.
17~
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be read the second time by council billpumber
only, with unanimous consent of the Council, and that enactment be consider~d at this time.
Motion carried unanimously and the bill was read the second time by council bill number only.
Mr. Mohr moved sec;onde.d by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approved and gi venfinal. passage. Rollcall,
"_ vote. All councilmen present voting aye, the bill was declared passed and_ numbered 16522.
Council Bill No. 9728 - Adopting plans and specifications for construction of sanitary
sewer and storm sewer within Somerset Hills and 160 feet adjacent to said subdivison, was .
submitted and read the first time by council bill number and title only, there being no councilman
present requesting that it be read in full.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be read the second time by council bill number
only, with unanimous consent of the Council, and that enactment be considered .at this time.
Motion carried unanimously and the bill was read the second time by council bill number only.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by ~s. Beal that the bill be approved and given final passage. Rollcall
vote. All councilmen present voting aye, the bill was declared passed-and numbered 16523.
Council Bill No. 9729 .,.. Construction of pedestrian w~ys as required wi thin Somerset Hills
Subdivision was submitted and read the first time by council bill number and title only, there
being no councilman present requesting it be read in full. .
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be read the second time by council hill number
I only, with unanimous consent of the Council, and that enactment be considered at this time.
Motion carried unanimously and the bill was read the second time by council bill number-only.
.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approved and given final p~ssage. Rollcall
vote. All councilmen present voting aye, the bill was declared passed and numbered 16524.
Council Bill No. 9730 - Paving 15th Avenue from Acorn Park to 300 feet west was submitted
and read the first time by council bill number and title only, there being no councilman present
requesting that it be read in full.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be read the second time by council bill number
only, with unanimous consent of the Council, and that enactmenfube considered at this time.
Motion carried unanimously and the bill was read the second time by council bill number only.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approved and given final passage. Rollcall
vote. All councilmen present voting aye, the bill was declared passed and numbered 16525.
I Council Bill No. 9731 - Adopting plans and specifications for paving 15th Avenue from
Acorn Park to 300 feet west wa s submitted and read the first time by council bill number and
title only, there being no councilman present requesting that it be read in full.
I
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be read the second time by council bill number
only, with unanimous consent of the Council ~ and that enactment be considered at this time.
. Motion carried unanimously and the bill was read the second time by council bill number only.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approved and given final passage. rollcall
vote. All councilmen present vo~ing aye, the bill was declared passed and numbered 16526.
I Council Bill No. 9732 - Construction of sidewalk on 15th Avenue from Acorn Park to 300 feet
west was submitted and read the first time by council bill number and title only, there being no
councilman present requesting that ifu ~e read in full.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be read the second time by council bill number
only, with unanimous consent of the Council, and that enactment be considered at this time.
Motion carried unanimously and the bill was read the second time by council bill number only.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approved and given final passage. Rollcall
vote. All councilmen present voting aye, the bill was declared passed and numbered 16527.
Council Bill No. 9733 - Construction of sanitary sewer to serve industrial lots between
West 1st and West 5th Avenues and between Bertelsen Road and Seneca Road was submitted and read.
the first time by council bill number and title only, there being no councilman present requesting
that it be read in full.
. Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be read the second time by council bill number
only-~-<,.dth-"~u1animoUs~cQhse~t of the Council, and that enactment be considered at this time.
Motion carried unanimously-and the bill was read the second time by council bill number only.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approved and given final passage. Rollcall
vote. All councilmen present voting aye, the bill was declared passed and numbered 16528.
Council Bill No. 9734 - Adopting plans and specifications for construction of sanitary
sewer to serve industrial lots between West 1st and West 5th Avenues and between Bertelsen Road
liD
r
and Seneca-Road was submitted and read,the ftrst time by council bill number and title only, there
being no. councilman present,'requesting that it be read in full. -
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be read the second time by council bill number
only, with unariimous consent of 'the 'CoUncil, and'that enactment be considered at this' time ~ -
Motion carried unanimOUSlY" and the bill was read the second time by' council bill number only ~ ._
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approvedahd given final passage. Rollcall
vote. All councilmen present voting aye; the bill was declared p~sed arid numbered 16529.
Council Bill No. 9735 - Construction of sanitary sewer between U. S.Highway 99 and 400
feet west and between 5th Avenue and 1700 feet northwest was submitted and read the first time by
council bill, number and title only, there being no councilTIian -present requesting that it be read
in full. '
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be read the second time by council bill number
only, with unanimous consent of the' Council; and that enactment be considered' at this time.
Motion carried UnEmimouSly and -the bill' was read' the second time by council bill- number only.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approved and given finalpassa:ge: Rollcall
vote. All councilmen present voting aye" the bill was d~cla~ed ~assed and numbered 16530.
Council Bill No. 9736 - Adopting plans and specifications for construction of sanitary
sewer between U. S. Highway 99 and 400 feet west and between 5th Avenue and 1700 feet northwest
was submitted and read the first tiTIie'by'council bill number and title only, there b~ing no
councilman presen t requesting that it be read in full.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Bear that' the bil,l be read the second time by c<?uncil bill number, .
only, with unanimous consent of the Council, and that enactment be considered at this time.
Motion carried unanimously and the bill was read the second time by council bill number only.
Mr. MohrHmoved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the bill be approved-arid :given final'passage. Rollcall
vote. All councilmen present voting aye, the bill was declared passed and numbere 16531.
_._~--_._--.-
IV -_ REsoiuTioNSc~H-- ----~-~~---~-~ C~__~"_ -~~~~---~- __uH -~~~--~~~~~~-----
Resolution No. 2064 - Approving and endorsing Civic Center Design Plan of December 1972,
:,_ was cSufmi,!ted.
Manager reviewed the Planning Commission recommendations (see committee minutes June 7,
'1972 - Planning Commission report May 22/23, 1972).
Councilman Mohr said he would like to speak to the issue of difference between the language
of the resolution, particularly integration of the plaza concept, and that of the Planning
Commission recommendation. Manager said it is assumed that in accepting the Commission's
qualifications, the resolution, upon adoption, would be so modified. He suggested, in
order to clarify the action, that the Commission's stipulations could be made an attach-
ment to the resolution when it has been adopted. ~
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal to adopt Resolution 2064. -7
Otto Poticha, 1820 Kona Street, commented on the lack of public notice or opportunity for
publi c hearing and discussion of the Design Plan, especially in view of its size -
covering approximately nine square blocks. With regard to the language of the resolution,
Mr. Poticha noted it does not include the Planning Commission recommendations, and that
although the first part is very general, the second part spe~ifically commits the City to
the plaza concept as the design of the plan. He said the design plan clearly indicates
four square blocks for clustering of buildings for the various agencies so one would assume
that building of the plaza and allocation of open space implies that it is the nine-block
area rather than the four-blo,ck area. Mr., Poticha noted the Planning Commission recom-
mendations indicated the plan does not fit the 1990 Plan. He said the number of proposed
parking stalls does not show leadership in helping to generate and promote mass transit
facilities. He further questioned whether a plaza is desired in view of the open space
required.
Dan Herbert, 4450 Hilyard Street, said the statement in the Civic Center Design Plan
with regard to transportation is in direct contradiction of many findings and objectives
of the transportation section of the 1990 Plan. He said the Transit District has adopted
a set of goals directed toward taking care of people who are wihtout, and do not have
access to, auto transportation system. Also, to begin activities directed toward induc- ~
ing people to use public transporration. He presented Council members with copies of -
proposed amendment to the resolution which would require environmental impact study on
the general concept and traffic provisions, and any future development of the Plan
must include specific provisions for alternatives. He feels his amendment will give a
more posi ti ve and affirmative stance on the issue. He added that the words "transporta-
tion facilities" should be used whenever reference is made to parking or off-street
parking.
111
Ed Whitelaw, 4801 Potter Street, said he does not approve in any way the Design Plan
because it includes low-density use in the plaza concept as well as very specialized
uses concentrated in a large area of the central city. He feels there is no substantive
meaning to the Plan as presented and no definite alternatives proposed. Also, that it
does not provide for citizen participation and review in that there is not enough informa-
tion about the Plan on which to base a critique.
4It Ralph Aldave, 4150 Pearl Street, speaking for the Upper Willamette Environmental Defense
. Agency, addressed remarks solely to environmental aspects of the Design Plan. He said
the entire notion of concentrated, integrated area for governmental services would de-
pend upon its environmental impact - noise, air pollution, requirements for transporta-
tion facilities, etc. He said if funds happen not to be available for mass transit
then the entire concept would have to be changed. He suggested questions with regard
to these problems should be answered first to determine whether environmental costs
will be higher than the advantage to be gained by an integrated center. He asked the
Council to take no action on the Design Plan; or if it is approved, that the resolution
be reworded to provide that any support facilities comply with all requirements of the
Federal government and Department of Environmental Quality; and, whatever action is
taken, that a study be implemented immediately to determine environmental impact of
the proposed Design Plan.
Alan Seder, 2385 McLean Boulevard, expressed the opinion that there is too much wasted
space in the Plan in providing for the plaza concept. He said the extent of Council
action should be only to say that the various governmental services will explore rela-
tionship of various levels of governments and then design and share space to accommodate
that relationship. The plan, he continued, is an inadequate way of planning for growth
and expansion of the services, and is probably 25 to 50 years obsolete.
.~
James Longwood, member of the architectural firm acting as consultants on the civic
center study, reviewed circumstances leading to development of the Design Plan - EWEB
purchase of property at 8th and Pearl, expansion of State building at 7th and Pearl,
consolidation of County services, vacation of School District building at 7th and High,
plans for location of a Federal building in this general area, etc. It was decided to
d;te;mine whether it was advisable to house all tha~kind ~f-development in this -area.
The team of consultants, in making that determination, was also charged with developing
a concept as part of the p~oject. Mr. Longwood further discussed the meetings of the
various departments of the several agencies to determine their needs in developing the
buildings and the plaza concept and providing for transportation. He said alternative
transportation schemes were discussed at many points - there was no 1990 Plan at that
time. The idea was to devise a concept which would allow for transportation needs
known at that time, and at the same time allow for alternative transportation if and
when it became available. He also discussed parking needs and location of facilities
to provide for those needs. He said the DEQ ,had a copy of the preliminary report on
this Design Plan when it was first issued, but there has been nothing received from them.
All in all, he feels the Plan represents a considerable step toward getting five levels
of government to consider collectively rather than individually what they want to do,
and approval of the Plan is requested on that basis.
~ I Manager disapproved some remarks made about competence of members of the design team
,., I and said he felt some response was necessary to belittling comments made. He noted
- that Mr. Longwood was a member of the firm which designed the City Hall and this build-
ing, Manager said, is the most successfully functioning building for governmental use
he was ever in. Manager said there is nothing in the plan to preclude use of mass
transit, hopefully it can succeed in replacing the need for the automobile, but use of
the auto as a major method of transportation to and from this type of facility cannot
be ignored. So far as the situation now with respect to this plan, it is necessary now
for official recognition of its desirability in order for the Federal government to de-
sign its building (to be located north of 7th between Pearl and High) to fit in with
the integrated concept. If it is to be assumed an integrated civic center will create
traffic problems and autos are not to be allowed, it would be better to abandon the
idea, because it will be necessary to move people to and from the center. Manager said
there is no question that further study of environmental impact is needed. However,
there is nothing in this plan designating this is what will actually be built. It ,is
a schematic concept showing how the various facilities can be accommodated in this general
area and suggests some alternatives which can be included with those developments going
ahead at this time. He expressed amazement that it would not be desirable to provide
considerable open space nor to have good pedestrian movement between the center and r
other pedestrian oriented facilities already located in the downtown area.
_ Mr. Aldave took exception to Manager's remarks and said he did not think it appropriate
. for Mr. McKinley as an employe of the City to express his views or to make rebuttal to
previous statements on this issue. Mayor Anderson answered that the Council would make
I judgment on Manager's remarks. He also disapproved remarks with regard to professional
, competence of people involved in the Design Plan. He cited the time and effort con-
, tributed, much without compensation, by many individuals in the design fraternity in
Eugene for the betterment of the community, and to question competence of these people
is highly questionable and in bad taste. Mr. Anderson said it is recognized there will
!1av~!c:l-EE:_trade-offs, ma!lY...E9! ;p~~asant, but no one can refute the implication that
1-----' lid.
I this Council does not support mass transit enthusiastically. He recalled the City's
I
role in helping the bus system to remain solvent, and said he feels the City is com-
mitted to mass transit system and will do everything it can to develop it. I
I'
I
Longwood, in answer to Councilman Mohr, said he support the stipulations recommended !
Mr. ,
by the Planning Commission. Councilman Mohr expressed the opinion that the Council is
being asked to give direction for formation of an intergovernmental committee that will
work in co-operation with the staff and Planning Commission and other agencies to set -
guidelines, but not to adopt a specific plan as such. He said he wanted to make it .
perfectly clear that the vote is on proper machinery to proceed with the problem sol v-
ing and development of guidelines. Adoption of the resolution with the attached ~.
Planning Commission stipulations will not commit the Council to adoption of the sub-
stance of the report.
Councilman Williams expressed. concern about transportation with regard to the advocacy
of not permitting use of autos to and from the center and the possibility of mass
transit system not operating effectively in a community of this size. He suggested
addition of language to the Planning Commission recommendation to the effect that
". . . nothing in the above shall be construed as a statement of the Council that movements
into and out of the City center should not be improved and developed as much as possible."
Mrs. Beal suggested inclusion of Mr. Herbert's amendment which provides that further
development of the Plan must include specific modes of transportation in accordance
with the 1990 Plan. She feels plaza with parking underneath more desirable than a
concentration of buildings surrounded by blacktop. Open space also would provide more
viable alternative for mass transit use.
Councilman Hershner said he doesn't find anything in the language of the resolution
gi ving an indication of pro-auto or anti-auto, it merely stated that there is left
open space. He would favor the resolution as presented with the stip~lations from the .
Planning Commission. Mr. McDonald concurred, also expressing concern about remarks
made with regard to development of the Desi.gn Plan.
Nayor Anderson noted that this resolution is being considered by allagenciea involved,
and felt it could be adopted wi~h cominents rather than changing its language.
Mr. Mohr moved seconded by Mrs. Beal that the motion be restated to adopt
the resolution with Planning Commission stipulations attached. Motion as
restated carried unanimously.
Councilman Mohr left the meeting.
Resolution No. 2065 - Initiating boundary change and transmitting to Boundary Commission
request for annexation of area north of Belt Line and east of River
Road (Fred Meyer, Inc.), was submitted.
Mrs. Beal moved seconded by Mr. Teague to adopt the resolution. Rollcall vote. All council-'
ment present voting aye, motion carried.
Resolution No. 2066 - Authorizing payment of bills, claims, and progress payments for period
May 22 to June~2, 1972, was submitted. -
.~
Mrs. Beal moved seconded by Mr. Teague to adopt the resolution. Rollcall vote. Motion
carried, all councilmen present voting aye.
Meeting was adjourned to Monday, June 26, 1972.
I
Hugh McKinley
City Manager
.
1'13