Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutResolution No. 3699RESOLUTION NO, 3 A RESOLUTION ADOPTING THE WILLOW CREED SPECIAL AREA STUDY AND AME NDING THE EUGENE - SPRINGFIELD METROPOLITAN AREA GENE PLAN. The City Council of the City of Eugene finds that: 11 The Eugene - Springfield Metropolitan Area General Plan established a portion of the willow Creek Basin as an important growth area of the community and included a portion of the Basin within the urban growth boundary of the Metropolitan Plan. 219 As part of the Metropolitan Plan process a variety of land uses were identified as appropriate within the Basin as urban development occurred. 3. In February, 1982, the Planning Commission directed that work be initiated on a Special Area Study in the willow Creek Basin in order to establish public policy direction prior to de- velopment proposals for the Basin. 4. As part of the development of � this Special Area Study a citizen involvement process was established by the Eugene Citizen Involvement Committee. The citizen involvement process included: dialogue with major land owners in the Basin; a May 25, 19 8 2 meet- ing held with residents and property owners of the Basin at Bailey Hill elementary school, attended by about 50 interested individuals; discussions and comments by interested parties through individual meetings; distribution of about 650 copies of the draft Study (May 1982) to property owners, residents, and interested governmental agencies; and consultation with the Metropolitan Area Plan Advisory Committee regarding the Special Area Study,, 5. The draft Study contained a series of policy statements and two alternative land -use configurations appropriate for the Willow Creek Basin. All of the policies are consistent with direction established by the Metropolitan General Plan. Alterna- tive 1 of the two land-use arrangements reflected an employment intensive scenario which could be appropriate for the Basin. Alternative 2 reflected a focus on residential development in the Basin. Because Alternative 1 provided for substantial motif ica- tions to the Metropolitan General, Plan ■ it requires an amendment to that document. Alternative 2 does not require such an amend- ment. Both alternatives contained a variety of land uses which were consistent with broad goals and policies established by the Metropolitan Plan, the 1974 Community Goals and Policies document, and the Eugene - Springfield Area Transportation 2000 Plan (T- 2000 ) . 6* On June 8,' 19 8 2 the Planning Commission conducted its public hearing on the willow Creek Special Area Study. About 12 Resolution - 1 � s individuals presented testimony to the Commission at this hearing. The ma l on ty of the testimony supported the Study and generally favored Alternative 1 - the employment intensive land -use alterna- tive. 7. The Commission continued its deliberation on the Study at its-meeting of June 14, 1982. At that time, based on testimony it received at the public hearing, its own discussion, and the background and supporting materials, including Statewide Goal and local plan consistency analysis (Exhibit A) , ' and justification for amendment to the Metropolitan Plan (Exhibit B) , the Commission unanimously voted to forward the following recommendations to the City Council: a. Adopt the willow Creek Special Area Study with Alterna 1; b, Initiate amendment procedures to the Metro- politan Plan following the process outlined in Chapter IV of that document; and C, Make a series of changes to the draft document. 8. The City Council initiated the Plan amendment procedure as prescribed in Chapter ITT of the Plan document, on June 16, 1982 91 On July 12, 1982, the City Council conducted its own public hearing of the Planning Commission's recommendations. This hearing addressed the willow Creek Special Area Study and possible amendment to the Metropolitan Plan. Now ■ therefore, based on the above findings and actions, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF EUGENE, a Municipal Corporation of the State of Oregon, as follows: Section 1 . The policies set forth in the willow -Creek Special Area Study are hereby adopted as a refinement to the Eugene - Springfield Metropolitan Area General Plan for the willow Creek Basin, and the explanatory text following the policies is recog- nized as clarifying and explaining the intent of the policies. Section. 2 . The Land Use Diagram included as recommended by the Planning Commission is recognized as clarifying and providing further explanation of the intent of the Metropolitan Plan Diagram. To the extent the Special Area Study Land Use Diagram is incon- sistent with the Metropolitan Area General Plan Diagram, the General Plan Diagram is hereby amended. Section 3 . The City Council adopts as additional findings, the supporting text, maps, and tables contained in the remainder Resolution -- 2 X699 of the Willow Creek Special Area Study'as recommended by the Planning Commission. Section 4 . The supporting materials concerning consistency with Statewide Goals as set forth in Attac A, (Jun 15 ■ 1982 and June 14, 1982 memoranda) , attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference, is recognized as providing further analysis, support, and findings for the adoption of this Special Area Study and Amendment of the General Plan Diagram. Attached. as further findings in support of these actions is Attachment B, supplementary findings, which are hereby adopted and the July 21, 1982 memorandum from the Planning Department, the findings and policy statements and amendments are likewise adopted. The foregoing Resolution adopted the day of July. 1982, A 1 010" 0*0 �/j I // e 0 0 0 City Recorder Resolution - 3 ATTACHMENT A -1 TO RESOLUTION NO. MEMORANDUM 399 O F THE CITY OF 'UGENE 5 OR "A Date: June la, 1982 To: Mayor and Council From: Planning Department Subj : Planning Commission Recommendations --- Willow Creek Special Area Study I . Introduction In February, 1982, the Planning Commission directed the staff to initiate work on a Special Area Study in the W i l l o w Creek Basin which has been identified in the Metro Plan as a major growth area for the community. The Commission felt it was important and appropriate to establish pubs i cal ly adopted guidelines for development of this area prior to consideration of major development proposals for land annexed to the City. On June 8, '1982, the Commission conducted its public hearing on the draft W i l l o w Creek Special Area Study. The draft Study contained a series of policy statements, elaboration and background material supporting those statements, and two alternate diagrams for consideration by the Commission. Alternative #1 reflected an employment intensive land-use arrangement, while Alternative #2 emphasized residential development in the Basin. Both alternatives contained a variety of land uses which were consistent with broad goals and pol i-ci es established by the Metro Plan, the 1974 Community Goals and Policies document, and T -2000. About twelve individuals presented testimony to the Commission at its hearing on this item. The majority of the testimony supported the Study and generally favored Alternative #1 -- the employment intensive land-use alternative. The Commission continued its deliberation on the Study until its meeting of June 14, 1982. At that time, based on testimony it received at the public hearing, its own discussion, and the background and supporting materials prepared by the staff, the Commission unanimously voted to forward the following recommendations to the City Council: 1 . Adopt the W i l l o w Creek Special Area Study with Alternative #1; 2 Initiate amendment procedures to the Metro Plan as outlined in Chapter IV of that document; and 3. Make a series of changes to the draft document. II. Proposed Technical Changes To Study The f o l l o w i n g techn changes to the draft were recommended to the Council and are shown in legisl format with underline indicating additions and parenthesis ( ) indicating deletions. 1. Modify the expl anaati on of policy A-1, pages 4 and 5 to read, "This policy is consistent with other pol i ci es in the Metropolitan Plan which provide for annexation of industrial land in conjunction with an approved capital improvement program that outlines provision of sanitary sewer service to an area. The Metro Plan policy also provides for interim sanitary sewer service through acceptable (to both the city and developer) facilities, such sewage lagoons, when a permanent servicing plan has been established through an adopted capital improvement program. Adoption of the City's capital improvement program for FY 1982 -83, which identifies the West Eugene Trunk as Eugene's highest priority for capital improvements, helps fulfill this policy direction. Finally, the Metro Plan contains policy language (policy #23, page III - B -6, Aug. 1980 Metro Plan and policy #18, page 26 and 19, page 6, 1952 Plan Amendments) which support an aggresive annexation program and servicing of designated industrial lands in order to have a sufficient supply of "development ready" land. In addition, this policy responds to Eugene's own economic diversification efforts as outlined in `� Eugene's Economic Diversification Program, Se t . 3 , 1981 which identifies industrial sitin as one strategy to imp rove the economic conditions of the community ^ 2. Policy A -2, page 5 change to read, "Exce as specially provided in Policy E-3, annexation of commercial and residential land shall be deferred at least until sanitary sewer service is available to the area, and other Eugene annexation requirements are met . " 3. Policy D -1, page 9, under explanation, change to read, "The community resource node concept is intended to maximize public investment by providing land for facilities which can be shared by various public, quasi = public , and appropriate private activities. Under this concept, Eugene would acquire land for the public resource node, making it available to various users, including a r❑ ri ate social service agencies Ultimately, si ting of the elementary school facility must be approved by the School Board of District 4J, taking into account location of other existing schools, attendance boundaries and other pertinent factors. In any event, the proposed future ac ui si ti on of this property should not be used to s_ top deve lopment Plans when other approRriate ubl i c criteria have been satisfied The ubl i c resource node on the Plan Diagram is merely meant to schematically demonstrate this conce t, and is not meant to 6 specific. 4. Policy E-3, page 10, change to read, "The City of Eugene shall encourage annexation of the wetlands area and properties under contiguous ownership in order to facilitate agreements fo.r public management between the property owners and The Nature Conservancy. In the short term a non -urban zoning classification, such as AG, Agriculture and Crazing, shall be -2- applied to these properties (until they are needed for urban levels of development) until ap ate conditions have been met to provide for urban development. 5. Page 18, Introduction to Section VII, add a new paragraph, "The pl a�n diagram, adopted as art of this S eci al Study study ' is intended to conceptually identify land- -use ' arrangements in the Basin, which would ultimately be implemented by other more specific actions For instance: the public resource node on the p an di a ram i s shown schematically to demonstrate the intent of the con ce t, and is not meant to be site specific; 2 neighborhood commercial facilities may be located in residential areas as part of the process of urbanization ; and 3� zonin and other implementation techniques will be used to specifical define land-use arra su ested by the plan d i a ram . 6. Add a new second paragraph to, the Introduction Section, page 1, to read as follows: "This study is in several sections as noted on the preceeding Table of Contents The first section lists the summary of the study and policies being recommended Each i n d i v i d u a l 01 i cy is followed by a brief discussion of the of i cy . Addi ti onal background information for the of i ci es as well as further discussion of the land use alternatives and el ements of the Wi llow creek Basin , are found in the latter sections 6 the Study Policies are adopted by the City Council as _guidance for decision-makin related to the Plan area � Ci ty programs actions and decisions such as zone changes traffic pat tern changes, and capital improvements, will be evaluated on the basis of their ability to implement these policies as well as other adopted city goals and pol i ci Because they are ado ted by the Council as the City's guide for action , op _l i ci es are the most important statements in the Study 7. On pages 5 and 6, modify the explanatory paragraph as follows, "On property with slopes and elevations which fit criteria to apply planned unit development procedures outlined in the South Hills Study, the PUD procedures (should) shall i ncl ude direction to. 1) mi nimize the effects of development on visual assets; 2) cluster development away from potential and identified problem soils, slopes and geologic conditions; and 3) maximize retention of existing vegetation. On properties in or adjacent to designated natural areas, the PUD procedures (should) shall include direction to: 1) transfer residential densities from natural resource areas to buildable portions of tax lots; 2) control storm drainage --- quantity and quality -- consequences on the natural area; and 3) use buffering techniques such as vegetative landscape barrier or fencing to protect the natural resource values of the site. On properties bordering stream courses, the PUD, cluster subdivision or site review procedures (should) shall include direction for retention of natural vegetation and buffering of the stream courses from development. This policy recognizes that under Eugene's planned unit development regulations, a variety of structure types and other neighborhood uses such as "neighborhood commercial" are allowed in any residential areas." -3- 8. Page 19, under Public Resource Node discussion, change second ` sentence to read as follows, "while these types of facilities are generally available within the community, this proposal conceives of them being clustered in one area and located in taxi mi t to other hi h -i ntensit land uses in the Basin". 9 . Page 25, under Plants and W i l d l i f e , change the first sentence in the second paragraph to read, "At least three rare plants (including the- Aster Curtis) do exist in the wet natural resource area of the Basin (see Map H)." 10. Page 23, Under Discussion of Size, change second sentence to read, "The special light industrial site in Alternative #2 is split into approximately (two 50 acre pieces) sixteen separate p arcels, possibly rendering it less desirable by a potential major firm. 11. Map E in the draft document, change to include footnote for Public Resource Node, and addition of high - density residential south of commercial designation (see revised Map E attached) . 12. Modify Map B in the draft willow Creek Special Area Study to show Eugene's City limits line (see revised Map B attached), EP LNG P LJ FM E M 5 -4- MAP 8 W4ETR B OUNDARIES.- • ■s��• CITY L I 1 T S URBAN RESERVE ..................... I .."mew Amam URBAN GROWTH BOUNDARY a• —••- -» PLAN BOUNDARY (ridgeline) 0 0 0 � a �::. °; �iE � d 0 Z ^c i �iie:� � :E °i::... cc J I. Q 0 0 cc 0 0 0000 z O J ESQ ii� _ � W .... .....:::::::::::::::::......... ...........:::........... ....... ........................... I. ....... a € €EEE fiE € ? ?SE fss� €5 €� S EA �� r'�5 € €€ i • €' �::s € E: sf ...............::::....: ::....::::....::.......:..:..:: :iii iiii ^i � m .... ................ ...................... ::iii i2i:iiii'iiE ?::ice ^:................... 'iE2E:iiEi:Eii�iE ii::ii isi::: ii::::iiii:cc ie:iEi::::: � J icEiiiiiii::. ::. ::::::::::: nn J im Z .low- 'R =40 9 ones$ **&s a of pop Alto%, & 4 00 4 WOR :: ■:04:9161: • 1111 ":511 0 11 :: *1 me* o w- d , do go " JOL will . 0 me ON go MR A 40 So ff 1k Ok FW# an 0 All F#11*1r a 40 rX - -Mom - Ron I =11p Coll (� •� N■ ■■ ■fir► ■����#��� � � � �. fill 9 I N No son 111MEROW i � - 8&93®R f � mv 01 MINI ■ i ----------------- Mom ARAM ----- ..... ..... Vm V z $ 0 0 w �u > own �o :L O Z < (.) LU z w 0 W Z so pa 01,111110 400 C 4w 4w c c c 11111111 OWNS cc 4 4w cc -C E 311b 0 *0 c :106 2 0 a ,� anial c c D E 0 E in E j to CL ca c ZW 0 2 va"*6 'ana" 2 !S Moll n 2 ATTACHMENT A -2 TO RESOLUTION NO. M E M O R A N D U M 3699 OF THE CITY OF EUGENE, OR Date: June 14, 1982 To: Mayor and City Council From: Planning Department 5ubj: Status Report /Plan Amendment Referral -- Willow Creek Special Area Study In February the P l a n n i n g Commission directed the staff to i n i t i a t e work on the Willow Creek Special Area Study. Staff work on that document was completed in May of this year. A copy of the draft document is attached to faci l i tate revi ew by the Mayor and Counci 1 . On June 8, 1952 the Planning Commission conducted its public hearing on the draft Study. Based on the background information and public testimony, the Commission has forwarded the following recommendation to the Council concerning the Willow Creek study: 1. Adopt the Study as modified by the Planning Commission (materials showing_ the Commission's recommended changes are being prepared); 2. Initiate an amendment to the Metropolitan Plan to reflect the fact that the recommended land -use diagram for the Basin is a modification to the arrangement and allocations envisioned in the General Plan. The adoption process for this study is intended to coincide with acknowledgement of the Metro Plan by the Land Conservation and Development Commission (LCDC). The acknowledgement process will also i ncl ude consideration of the Willow Creek Special Area Study. To accomplish this objective, a tentative schedule has been prepared ( to the inside front cover of the Study). In order to maintain the tentative time schedule, the Council will be requested to initiate referral of a plan amendment to the City of Springfield and Lane County at the Council meeting of June 15. This action merely refers the proposal to the other two jurisdictions for comment. It would and should not commit the Council to a predetemi ned course of action. Because of the generalized nature of the Metro Plan, it should be refined in specific areas. In most cases, these changes or refinements will not require a plan amendment and formalized modifications to the Metropolitan Plan. However, when changes cross a threshold of impact, i.e. when amendments would cause major changes to the Plan, then the plan amendment process should be implemented. The recommendations of the Planning Commission emphasize employment generating activities in 'the Basin and, because of the change from the Metro Plan, would involve a plan amendment. The Planning Commission's recommendation would reflect: 1. A major special light industrial site for activities involving manufacture of high-technology I products located i in the center of the Basin, taking advantage of the gently rolling terrain in the area; Z. Designation of land for light - medium industrial activities at the northern edge of the Basin along West 11th Ave.; 3. Medium-and high - density residential development clustered in proximity to the employment centers in Willow Creek to encourage the use of alternative modes of transportation; 4. Location of commercial activities at the northern edge of the Basin in proximity to light-medium i ndustri al activities and major transportation corridors. In order to facilitate the review by other jurisdictions, the staff has prepared a series of materials that would be included in justifying an amendment to the Metro Plan reflecting direction established by the Planning Commission's re.commendati on . Attachment A provides a discussion of the consistency of the Special Study with the Statewide Goals. Attachment B provides a discussion of support and needs for an amendment to the adopted Eugene - Springfield Metropolitan Area General Plan as a result-of the Planning Commission's recommendation on the W i l l o w Creek Special Area Study. Attachment A Statewide Goal s Although Statewide goals 1 through 14 are applicable to the Willow Creek Special Area Study, Goals 5 (Open Space), 8 .(Recreational Needs), 9 (Economy), 10 (Housing), 11 (Public Facilities and Services) and 14 (Urbanization) are particularly salient. While LCDC goals are dealt with in the policy section of this Study, pertinent goals are also discussed in other sections of the Study as follows: St Goal 1, Goal 2, Goal 3, Goal 4, Goal 5, Goal 6, Goal 7, Goal H, Goal 9, Goal lo, Goal 11, Goa 1 121' Goal 13, Goa1 14, atewi de Goals Citizen Involvement Land Use Planning Agricultural Lands Forest Lands Open Spaces, Scenic and Historic Areas, and Natural Resources Ai r, Dater and Land Resources Quality Areas Subject To Natural Hazards Recreational Needs Economy Of The State Housing Public Facilities And Services Transportation Energy Conservation. Urbani zati on Special Study Discussion Section III Sections I, IV and VII Section VIII Section VIII Section VIII Section VIII Section VIII Section VI Section VII Section VII Section V Section IX Sections VII and IX Sections VI, VI, VII, VIII and IX The following is a discussion of the consistency between the W i l l o w Creek Special Area Study and the Statewide Goals. Goal 1 --- Citizen Participation: To develop a citizen involvement program that insures the opportunity for citizens to be involved in all phases of the planning process. Discussion: Development of the W i l l o w Creek Special Area Study occurred through the benefit of several citizen involvement techniques: 1. The area was identified as a major growth area through development of the Eugene-Springfield Metropolitan Area General Plan. Development of this planning document occurred over a period of about five years and involved over 250 public meetings and hearings. Major changes to the Metropolitan Plan will involve further public hearings through an established plan amendment process. 2. Development of the Willow Creek Special Area Study involved discussion with representatives of some of the A -1 major property owners in the Basin to gain their comments on staff proposals. 3. Other property owners and residents were contacted on an individual basis through mai 1 i ngs of the draft study. This involved distribution of over 600 copies of the draft Study, and an informational meeting conducted at Bailey H i l l Elementary School on May 25, 1982. In these reviews, the staff discussed (either through meetings or phone conversations) ideas with and questions from of a number of area property owners. 4. Because the Willow Creek Basin represents one of the major growth areas of the City (into the 21st century) , and because it is currently sparsely populated, the Planning Commission itself plays an important role in advocating for future generations of Eugeneans. This involves balancing the Commission's role as policy developers with one which assesses the needs and desires of the future citizens living or working in the Basin. MAPAC will have an opportunity to formally comment on the proposed amendment. 5. The Metropolitan Area Plan Advisory Committee (MAPAC), citizen involvement body for metropolitan wide planning, has received continuous status reports and updates concerning development of this Study. This provided a metropolitan-wide perspective on public policy development for the Ali 11 ow Creek Basi n . The City's Citizen Involvement program received acknowledgement in 1978 by the Land Conservation and Development Commission (LCDC) as part of the overall acknowledgement of Eugene's comprehensive planning program. Development of the Basin w i l l continue to involve citizen input and discussion through the public hearing processes which are part of public actions such as annexations or rezoni ngs . Moreover, Lane County is holding hearings on this proposed plan amendment, affording yet another mechanism for citizen involvement. Goal 2 w-- Land Use Planning-, To establish a land use planning process and policy framework as a basis for all decisions and actions related to use of land and to assure an adequate factual base for such decisions and actions. Discussion: A series of working papers containing information on current land inventories and projected demands have been developed. For a variety of reasons, including public cost efficiencies, the Metro Plan identified the willow Creek Basin as a major growth area. The Wi 11 ow Creek Special Area Study outlines a series of policy statements consistent with adopted direction established by the - Eugene-Springfield Metropolitan Area General P l a n , Eugene's Community Goals and Policies and Eugene's Economic Diversification Program. Policies outlined in the Study are designed to more specifically apply the development needs and public actions which w i l l occur within the W i l l o w Creek Basin as part of the normal urbanization process. W 1. The working papers referred to above were. derived from an t inventory, review and analyi s of a number of relevant elements conducted as part of the development of the Metropolitan Plan. These elements included population projections, land use and housing (supply and demand) , public facilities and utilities, and natural assets and constraints. The " Metroplitan Area General Plan, Technical Supplement," is a product of these working papers. 2. Discussion of alternative land use arrangements reflecting an emphasis on residential use in the W i l l o w Creek Basin is contained in the original draft of the Spec a l Area Study. 3. Coordination of the proposed plan amendment has occurred through: (a)consultations with and requests for comments from affected public agencies; referral and comments by other City departments; and (c) referral, through processes outlined in the Metropolitan Plan, of a proposed amendment to that document to the City of Springfield and Lane County. 4. No exceptions to the LCDC' s Goal #2 w i l l be required by t h i s plan amendment since any Goal #2 issues have been addressed through adoption of the Metropolitan Area General Plan. 5. To the extent that the proposed plan amendment occurs shortly after acknowledgement of the Metro Plan, such an immediate amendment is necessary for the following reasons: (a) Experience in continuing economic development programs of the City of Eugene suggests that the major special light industrial site in the W i l l o w Creek Basin is quite attractive to large special light industrial firms. This conclusion is based on discussions with at least one such firm. Based on those discussions, it can be concluded that advanced planning for the Willow Creek Basin, reflecting the proposed amendment to the Metro Plan, will further the City`s efforts to diversify its local economic base -- an established goal of the City Council. (b) Competition for such si ti ngs is intense both within and outside the State. City involvement in this competition reveals strong l ocati oval advantages for the City of Eugene through proximity to the University of Oregon, lack of competition of existing high-technology firms for a local "labor pool" , and cultural and recreati onal amenities for employees. This general competitive edge will require supplemental action to provide a variety of sites (both in terms of sizes and locations) which can respond to the needs and requirements of potential high- technology firms. (C) The original comprehensive plan placed special light industrial designation upon a property not clearly suitable for those purposes by virtue of diversity of .ownership and lack of a stheti c qualities, among other factors. The need for a plan amendment at this time is justified in order to correct this problem. A -3 Goal 3 -- Agricultural Lands: 'To preserve and maintain agricultural lands. Discussion: The Study provides di sussi on of soils conditions in the Basin. The Study notes that the Basin contains some of the least productive agricultural soils in the metropolitan area, generally consisting of Class III and Iii rated agricultural soils, with isolated pockets of Class II soils on the flatland and Class VI soils in the upper portions of the Basin. The Study concludes discussion on agricultural uses in the Basin by noting that during deve l opment , of the Metropolitan Plan, the relatively low degree of potential agricultural productivity in the Basin was compared with other areas having greater agricultural productivity. For this reason, among others, the Basin was identified as a major growth area of the City and included within the adopted, site specific urban growth boundary with commitment to urban levels of development during the planning period. Focussing development in this part of the metropolitan area reduces pressures for urbanization on valuable farm land to the north. The reallocation of special light industrial sites occasioned by the proposed plan amendment will not affect agricultural operations in a degree different from the impact of the unamended Plan. Goal 4 -- Forest Lands: To conserve forest lands for forest uses. Discussion: Designation of the Basin for urban development through the Metropolitan General Plan effectively precluded lands within the urban growth boundary for potential use as commercial forests. However, Goal 4 also recognizes forested lands as significant for uses such as watershed protection measures and situations where soil and topographical conditions require maintenance of vegetative cover. The Special Study, through a series of proposed policies, address these latter conditions. Policy A -4 addresses a variety of issues including those identified in Goal #4. It calls for the use of planned unit development, site review and cluster subdivision procedures to address environmental issues of slope; geologic and soil conditions; properties in or adjacent to designated natural areas; and properties along natural stream courses. Policy E -1 directs the City to work with Lane County to protect forested slopes between the city limits and the ri dgel i ne of the Basin. This policy suggests that one appropriate method of achieving this objective would be to utilize as a model, Eugene's tree cutting ordinance (currently only i o n effect within the City's 1 imits) . Goal #5 -- Open Spaces, Scenic and Historic Areas, and Natural Resources: To conserve open space and protect natural scenic resources. Discussion: A major p ❑ftT ❑n of the W i l l o w Creek Special Area Study is devoted to discussion of protection of natural resources. Proposed policies A -4 and E -1 (see Goal #4 discussion above) , as well as C-3, D -1 E -2 and E -3 focus on Goal #5 issues. Policy C--3 addresses the concern for protecting the wetlands area while controlling storm run-off (see Goal #6 for further discussion) . Policy D -1 would direct the City to explore the possibility of acquiring land to site a variety of public services including a major park site and community center. Discussion in the Study itself details the use of this major park facility as w e l l as smaller park facilities anticipated to be located throughout the Basin. Policy E -2 of the Study would direct the City to acquire through a variety of mechanisms A -4 a continuous corridor system along the ri dge l i ne of the Basin (continuing a program already underway in the City's south hills) as well as an interconnecting environmental /recreational /storm drainage system throughout the Basin. This policy emphasises the importance' of similar programs existing in the City and their application to the Basin itself. Policy E -3 focuses on public actions which can be taken to protect a sensitive wetland area, which has a variety of rare plants. Policy E -3 identifies public actions which should occur to encourage an appropriate balance between the need to preserve this sensitive natural area and provide for urban development in the Basin. In part, the allocation of a s i g n i f i c a n t quantity of land for special light industrial uses reflects a concern for the retention of open space through the development of a "campus -like" setting for such facilities. To the extent this proposed plan amendment creates a larger light industrial site for this purpose, it advances the policy of Goal #5 as consistent with open space values. Goal 6 -- Air, Water and Land Resources Quality: To maintain and improve the quality of the air, water and land resources of the state. Discussion: The nodal development concept upon which the Study is ,based, provides for the opportunity to cluster development around service and employment activities which positively affect land and air quality of the area. This responds to direction established through the Metropolitan Plan. The issue of water *quality is specifically addressed through proposed Policy C -3 which would direct the City to conduct study of appropriate measures to control storm run-off. The discussion of this policy notes that a balance must be maintained between the protection of the bottom land in the Basin from storm run -off and the need to maintain an adequate moisture level (both quantity and quality) for vegetation in the protected natural areas. Little significant impact upon air, water and land resource quality can be anticipated by the reallocation of industrial lands through the proposed plan amendment. Creation of a large special light site may facilitate single ownership and control over siting of facilities, thereby increasing the ability to develop more unified and e f f i c i e n t waste control measures. Goal 7 -- Areas Subject To Natural Disasters And Hazards: To protect life and property from natural disasters and hazards. Discussion: The Study provides detailed discussion of potential natural hazard areas in the Basin. Policy A -4 would direct the City to utilize land use mechanisms such as planned unit developments, site review procedures and cluster subdivisions to respond to these hazard areas. Policy C -3 would direct the City to conduct an analysis and implement appropriate measures to deal with urban level storm - run -off from the Basin. This policy notes that care should be taken to ensure that appropriate moisture levels ( quantity and quality) be maintained to protect vegetation in the natural area. Goal 8 -- Recreational Needs: To satisfy the recreational needs of the citizens of the state and visitors. (See also discussion of park and trail systems under Goal 5.) Discussion: The Special Study contains. discussion of both passive and active recreati on'al needs for the Basin. It sets forth public policy which will assist in preserving sensitive natural areas and corridors, and A-5 attaining public access to these properties. It also focusses on active recreational needs of present and future residents of the Basin and establishes policy to further investigate siting of a public resource node which would contain, among other facilities, a community center and major park. Goal 9 --- Economy Of The State: To diversify and and improve the economy of the state. Discussion: The need to diversify the local economy has been well established over the past fifteen to twenty years. During the last five years, efforts have been intensified to achieve economic diversification objectives of the community. The study responds to Goal 9 direction by establishing public policy to actively annex lands designated for industrial use in the Basin, and reaffirms the city's commitment to expedite extension of sanitary sewer service to the Basin -- a critical factor in the siting of employment' intensive firms. The study al so responds to - Goal 9 di recti on by e stabl i shi ng l and -use patterns wh i ch wi 11 be attractive to firms seeking "campus -like environments" (also see discussion under Goal #2 above.) Goal 10 -- Housing: To provide for the housing needs of the state. Discussion: The Metropolitan Area General Plan established the W i l l o w Creek' Basin as a primary growth area for the city and metropolitan community. The study refines this direction by providing direction to locate multiple - family housing in proximity to employment, commercial and service opportunities. Finally, the Study responds to direction established in the Metro Plan to keep a six -to -ten year supply of residential land in the City's limits by establishing annexation policy for residential land i n - t h e Basin. It must be recognized, however, that the plan amendment would result in less acreage available for residential development within the Basin. In considering this reallocation, Goal #10 concerns have been addressed through a variety of measures, including retention of medium-and high - density housing designations on land in the northeastern portions of the Basin. Reduction in the amount of low - density residential land will not affect the market for various types of housing in the metropolitan area, because-, (a) The overall supply of low - density residential land anticipated by the Metro Plan is adequate to meet projected demands for this housing type. (b) The Metropolitan Plan anticipates timing of residential land well into the future (estimated year 2000) . If more quantity of this type of land is required, the factors affecting land supply, such as timing and delivery of public services, can be reevaluated in the future. Goal 11 -- Public Facilities And Services: To plan and develop a timely, orderly and efficient arrangement of public facilities and services to serve as a framework for urban and rural development. Discussion: Through adoption of the 1990 General Plan in 1972, the Eugene--Springfield Metropolitan Area established one of the first urban growth boundaries in the State. As subsequently mandated by the Land A -6 Conservation and Development Commission, the urban growth boundary is the outer edge of an area to receive urban levels of public services over a specific planning period. The concept has worked well in this area. With adoption of the Metro Plan (updating the 1990 Plan), the urban growth boundary was expanded to include parts of the Willow Creek Basin. The Metro Plan programmed this area to provide a portion of the required land inventory needed for orderly growth of the community to about the year 2000. The W i l l o w Creek Special Area Study i denti f fes a series of public facilities needed to ultimately provide service for the Basin, and provides direction to implement these projects . Notably, the Study identifies the fact that police, fire and services and some elementary school capacity can be provided through existing facilities. Goal 12 -- Transportation-, To provide and encourage a safe, convenient and economic transportation system. Discussion: The Eugene-Springfield Area Transportation 2000 '(T-- 2000) Plan contains policy and capital project requirements intended to guide development of the area's transportation systems to the end of the century. While it identifies the street and highway network as the backbone of the system, it also calls for efforts to encourage use of alternate modes of transportation such as bicycling, walking, transit and paratransit. The Study contains a series of policies which respond to that direction. The study also provides for a clustering of several land- use activities through a "nodal development" to facilitate walking and bicycling, as well as efficient transit and paratransit service. Goal 13 -- Energy Conservation: To conserve energy. Discussion: ,The nodal development concept (discussed in Goal 12 analysis above) i s critical to both local and State energy conservation efforts. Facilitating alternative modes of transportation is one method of achieving conservation of petroleum-based fuels. The Study also encourages construction of multi - family housing types, which are more energy efficient than single - family units, both during construction and use. Finally, development of the Basin will occur under city-wide codes including Eugene's solar access provisions which maintains passive and active solar energy options for current and future residents of the area. To the extent that increased employment will occur in the Basin by virtue of the proposed plan amendment, it w i l l fac i l i ti ate worker residency near places of employment, thereby promoting energy efficiencies. Goal 14 -- Urbanization: To provide for an orderly and efficient transition from rural to urban land. Discussion: Provisions of this goal direct the following: Land within the boundaries separating urbani zabl e land from rural land shall be considered available over time for urban uses. Conversion of urban i zabl e land to urban uses shall be based on consideration of: 1. Orderly, economic provision for public facilities and a services; 2. Availability of sufficient land for various uses to insure choices in the market place; A- 7 3. LCDC goals; and 4. Encouragement of devel opme.nt within urban areas before conversion of urban i zabl a areas. As noted in the draft Study and analysis of other Statewide Goals (see for example Goals 2, 3 and 11) , the Willow Creek Basin has been identified in the adopted Eugene - Springfield Metropolitan Area General Plan as a major growth area of the community and included within the adopted urban growth boundary of that document. This is consistent with earlier a n a l y s i s conducted by the city of Eugene, which identified the western and southwestern portions of the metropolitan area as primary growth areas for Eugene and indicates that these areas can: 1. be provided with public services in the most cost- effective manner; 2. provide a choice of land for future residential, industrial and commercial activities in order to respond to various market needs; 3. respond to direction established by the Statewide Goals; and 4. respond to local goals to maintain a compact urban growth form. These are examples of the reasons that the Willow Creek Basin was ultimately chosen to be included within the urban growth boundary. The W i l l o w Creek Special Area Study refines broad land-use allocations for the Basin provided in the Metropolitan Plan, and through policies addresses the need to accomodate some of the metropolitan areas long-range growth anticipated in the Metro Plan. The W i l l o w Creek Study attempts to balance the need for intensive land uses and employment opportunities with the need to respond to existing conditions, e.g. environmental concerns, as part of the urbanization of the Basin. Early annexation of the industrial ly -designated land and the wetlands area is meant to fulfill the local goals of providing a sufficient supply of development-ready industrial land and to protect a Goal 5 resource. As Policy A--2 of the Study provides, conversion of the remainder of the Basin from urbani zabl e to urban land will be deferred. The Study also responds to a basic premise of the compact urban growth concept which directs that, intensive urban land-uses most appropriately occur within an approved urban growth boundary --- a foundation of Goal 14 concerns. Remaining Goals 15 through 19 -- Not Ap-pl i cabl e . Attachment B Consistency with Local Policy Documents INTRODUCTION During the 1970s, two basic planning concepts were established i n Eugene that directly affect future development of the W i l l o w Creek Basin: l) The western and southwestern portions of the metropolitan -area were established as the primary growth areas for Eugene for at least the remainder of this century. The Metropolitan - Area General Plan reinforces this policy direction by identifying the Willow Creek Basin as an important development area for Eugene. 2) The concept of development nodes was established in the mid-1970s. Development nodes are meant to provide facilities for living, working, recreation and commerce within one general area. The development node concept is especially critical in responding to adopted policies pertaining to compact urban growth, efficient use of public services and gaining maximum efficiency from the area l s transportation system. This concept was first established through the Goodpasture Island Study (June 1975), and further refined in the Coburg - Crescent Special Area Study (July 1981) . Recognizing the value of the concept, the Metro Plan calls for nodal development patterns in the Willow creek Basin. Because of its location in the southwestern portion of the metropolitan area, the Basin is a logical continuation of the physical, economic and social growth of the city of Eugene. The purpose of the Special Area Study is to establish more specific policy direction and land -use arrangements in the southwestern portion of the metropolitan area -- the W i l l o w Creek Basin. The willow Creek Basin is important for the future development of the community because: 1. It is in proximity (approximately 10 minutes driving) to Mahlon Sweet Field, the regional airport for the southern Willamette V a l l e y ; 2. It is within 15 minutes driving time to downtown Eugene; 3. It contains large undeveloped parcels, which will provide flexibility for future development as it occurs in the Basin; 4. It has interesting and varied topographical and environmental. features providing a unique setting, which w i l l be attractive to new business and residents of the Basin; and 5. It provides an opportunity for the community to encourage development while meeting goals pertaining to compact urban growth and transportation. m The following comprise major changes to the Metropolitan Plan diagram (no text amendments are required) which would result from the Planning Commission's recommendation 1. Redesignate land (about 100 acres) at the northern edge of the Basin from special-light industrial to light-- medium industrial; 2. Redesignate land (about 230 acres) generally shown for low- density residential in the center of the Basin to special-light industrial; 3. Designate all land at the western edge of the Basin between the urban growth boundary and West 11th as medium-density residential . ,The need for diversification of the local economic base is well documented. Currently, while unemployment rates for the metropolitan area are not officially calculated, data available from the State Department of Labor placed the seasonly adjusted March 1982 unemployment rate for Lane County at 13.1 %. This is higher than the national and State averages and reflects a continued dependence upon certain types of employment activities throughout the entire County. Seven documents developed over the last few years are pertinent to the discussion of need for alteration to land use arrangements for the Wi 11 ow Creek Basi n as outl i ned i n the Metro PI an. A. Metro Plan Context. The entire W i l l o w Creek Basin was considered for inclusion within the urban growth boundary established by ,the Eugene-Springfield Metropolitan Area General Plan Ultimately, only a portion of the Basin was contained in the adopted Metro Plan, with the remainder designated urban reserve. Map B of the draft Study shows areas within the urban growth boundary and urban reserve areas adopted as part of the Metro Plan. These actions are supported by a series of background documents including Eugene's "Growth Management Studies - -Phases I and II ", and working papers. developed and technical supplement developed for the Metro Plan itself. By identifying the Basin for future growth of the community, the Metro Plan established the foundation for eventual urbanization of the area. The Metro Plan as well as other planning documents of the City of Eugene have established over time a nodal development concept which is meant to provide facilities for living, working, recreation and commerce within one general area. Other development nodes in Eugene include the downtown area, Goodpasture I s l a n d Road and the Coburg - Crescent area. The Planning Commission's recommendation, which involves an amendment to the Metro Plan involves, several changes to that document. All relate to land-use configurations generally depicted on the plan diagram. However, the proposed changes are consistent with and supported by adopted policies in the Metro Plan which provide a broad basis for public policy decisions within the metropolitan area. The proposed amendments are also consistent with the technical assumptions supporting the Metropolitan Plan diagram and the urban growth boundary. room B. Metropolitan P l a n Support For P l a n Amendment. A total of seven special light i ndustri al sites (about 885 gross acres total) are designated in the Metro Plan. Those seven sites were not designated to meet projected employment demand; they were designated to respond to goals regarding diversification of the local economy. A number of sites were designated to meet two objectives: (1) allocation of sites to meet the cities of Springfield and Eugene needs; and (2) allocation of sites in various size, configurations, and locations to allow choice among several sites by potential special light i ndustri al firms. used for selecting the seven s i t e s in the Metro P l a n include: (1) large scale --- in excess of 50 acres; (2) five or fewer ownerships; (3) good access to transportation facilities -- especially highways; (4) buffered from detracting surrounding urban uses; (5) campus -like atmosphere; and (6) the ability to extend services to the s i t e . The following table summarizes size and ownership information for each site designated in the Plan. Jurisdiction Name Approximate Size Number Of (Gross Acres) Ownerships Springfield N Gateway 185 5 Springfield Pierce 60 1 Eugene Cone - Breeden 115 1 Eugene West Park 110 2 Eugene Spectra - Physics 120 4 Eugene West Terry 200 2 Eugene S llth(Willow Creek) 95 8 Seven Sites 885 Total Gross Acres Of the total 885 gross acre, the following assumptions we.re used in developing the P l a n : Public right -of -way (20% of gross) = 175 acres Devoted to commercial use (10 acres per site) = 70 acres Buffering /landscaping (20% of gross) = 175 acres Net industrial use acreage = 465 acres 885 acres By amending the Plan to substitute a 230--acre W i l l o w Creek special light industrial site for the 95 -acre South 11th site, the gross acreage for that designation in the Metro Plan would be about 1,020 acres, and the net special light i ndustri al acreage would become approximately 590 acres. The amendment would not require alternation to the urban growth boundary. In its analysis of the treatment of the special light industrial sites, the Industrial Study Task Force considered a March 5, 1980, memorandum from the Metropolitan Area Planning Advisory Committee (MAPAC), "Industrial Allocations in the draft Metropolitan Area General Plan." In that memorandum, MAPAC examined 17 alternative sites, including the W i l l o w Creek Basin. The proposed 230 acre site was within a larger area examined by MAPAC. MAPAC concluded the following regarding the W i l l o w Creek site: There is potential to designate one or two sites in the W i l l o w Creek Basin. Because there is ample vacant land in relative large parcels, sites ranging from 50 to 200 acres in size could be identified. The relationship of Willow Creek to the West Eugene Industrial Area, and the Eugene east--west corridor identified in the adopted Transportation Plan and the relationship to other special light manufacturing sites identified in the draft Plan (see shaded areas) and the Spectra- Physics site (also shaded, see discussion under #1 in this report) have a bearing on a possible designation in the W i l l o w Creek Basin. - A range of options or combinations thereof are available, including: (1) Expansion of the 130 -acre site already identified in the draft Plan; it could easily be expanded to 200 acres and medium - density uses could be shifted into the W i l l o w Creek Basin or areas south of West 11th. (2) Locate a site outside the draft urban growth boundary in the Willow Creek Basin. (3) Locate a site on the "speedway" property and shift medium and high density residential uses to other locations within the Willow Creek Basin. West 11th and Beltline provide good transportation access to the W i l l o w Creek Basin. Improvements to West 11th between Beltline and Green Hill Road would improve access to the airport. Advantages - Planned transportation improvements (Terry Streets, 6th -7th Extension) and planned sanitary sewer improvements (Terry Street or nest Eugene trunkline and ancillary improvements) will open opportunities for annexation and development in the west Eugene region. Willow Creek presents a drainage basin which is largely undeveloped and provides excellent opportunities for developing a balanced land use system which, if properly planned, can complement development and planning already completed 'within adjacent areas of the city. The Basin is attractive and the large parcels provide the locational flexibility mentioned previously. A southward extension of Beltline to 20th (See Map No. 8) would provide improved access to parcels south of 20th. r The close proximity of the 230 acre site to other west Eugene special • light industrial sites would be beneficial. In addi ton , the Willow Creek site would be nearby housing. of the other Eugene sites, only the Cone - Breeden site offers similar opportunities'. The proposed 230 acre site is in one ownership. If the Plan is amended, it would become the only site over 160 acres with parcels in one contiguous ownership. The amendment would fulfill a need to have a site of greater than 200 acres. Testimony at local hearings on industrial land allocations have often focussed on such a need. While the special light industrial site designated as part of the Metro Plan process responds to these criteria, the land use arrangements proposed by the Eugene Planning Commission better meets direction provided by these criteria and other Plan policies. I. size - The approximately 200 -acre special light industrial site in Alternative #1 is in one ownership and can provide siting potential for a major user. The special light industrial site in Alternative #2 is split by W i l l o w ' Creek Road into approximately two 50-acre pieces, possibly rendering it less desirable by a potential major firm. 2. Ownership Patterns - The special light site designation, resulting from the Planning Commission's recommendation, is in one ownership. This compares to the fragmented ownership pattern (see above table) existing in the site designated by the Metro Plan. The ownership pattern occurring in the proposed amendment mitigates land assemblage problems and make this site more attractive for use by a major firm. 2. Access - While Alternative #2 currently has access to a major arterial (West .11th Avenue) , upon extension of the proposed arterial facility south from Bel.tl i ne Road, the access to the special light industrial site in Alternative #1 would be superior. 3. surrounding Uses - The topography of the site in Alternative #1 provides natural buffering from existing transitional heavy industrial uses to the north. 4. Campus-Like Environment - Some firms do ' prefer gently rolling topographical condi tons . The site in Alternative #1 contains this type of condi ton . In addition, the site in Alternative #1 would provide unobstructed views to the scenic forested hills to the south and the natural wetlands area to the east. The projected demand for Metropolitan housing units within the three residential density designations and the amounts allocated within the adopted urban growth boundary are shown in the following table: B--5 Plan Residential Projected Demand Allocations Result Of Designation (No. of D . U . s) (No. of D . U . s) ail w Creek Amendments Low Density 42 43,925 42 Medium Density 10,280 14,965 13,896 High Density 4 5,650 5,650 59 64 62,171 *Note: This total includes 2,400 multiple-family units assumed for downtown Eugene. The shift in land uses from residential to industrial within the Willow Creek Basin does not jeopardize either the overall allocation of dwelling units or the al l Qcati ons among the three residential density categories within the urban growth boundary. The shift does not necessitate an expansion of the urban growth boundary to accommodate units which would be "lost" through a change in the Plan designation. In addition to the poi nts noted above, the Planning Commission's recommendation provides a residential land use arrangement which responds more efficiently to goals and policies of the community pertaining to balanced land use and compact urban growth. This occurs through clustering of the multiple-family land uses around the major servi and employment centers, i . e . commercial and industrial land uses. Several statements in the Metropolitan Plan support the proposed plan amendment. The Goal, Finding #5, Objectives #4, #5, and #8, and Policies #19 and #22 found in the Economic Element of the Metro Plan, all support modifications which would reflect a larger special light industrial site located in the central portion of the Basin, Essentially these statements outline one strategy to respond to the need to diversify the local economic base. They direct the reservation of several areas within the urban growth boundary for large-scale, campus -type, light manufacturing ,uses, continually evaluating other si tes. i n . and around Springfield and Eugene for potential light-medium industrial and special-light industrial uses. Shifting of the special- light industrial site to the central portion of the Basin and designation of property at the northern edge of the Basin to light - medium industrial use responds to this direction. C. 1974 Community Goals and Policies Document. The 1974 Community Goals and Policies Document support the need to diversify the local economy. Policies #2 a and #2 b direct the City to pursue efforts which would diversify the local economy. D. Eugene And Site Selection By High Techonol gy Firms, Economic Consultant Oregon, May 1981 r � �J � r This document addresses concerns of high technology firms i n re] ati on to si ti ng of new faci l i ti es. Fi rms surveyed as part of thi s study rated their preferences for different combinations of topography and vegetation. The results reflected a strong preference for high -image sites. Shifting of the special light industrial site to the center of the Basin responds to this desire and would provide Eugene with an expanded inventory of attractive sites for major high-technology firms . E. Industrial Lands Task Force Report. The report of the Industrial Lands Task Force, April 1981, reviewed and supplemented findings and policies pertinent to industrial locations outlined in the Metro Plan. The report finds that; 1. Important locational factors indentified for high - techno l ogy firms i ne l ude proper plan designation, proper zoning designation, availability of public ci services, compatability with existing and future surrounding uses and image of the site. 2. The report also concluded that some of the largest electronic firms ( as Tektronix and Hewlett-Packard) are interested in sites of 150 acres, but noted that other smaller fi rms* (compri the majority 'of the potential users) were interested in sites between 10 and 50 acres in s i z e . 3. In relation to light-medium i ndustri al activities, the Report notes that the most recent industrial growth in the metropolitan area has been almost entirely in the light - medi um category. 4. The Task Force Report recommended that until more is l earned about the demand for light-medium i ndustri al land, the cities should continue to maintain a variety of sites, fully serviced, in a variety of locations. W hile the special light industrial site designated as part of the Metro Plan responds to some of these criteria, the land use arrangements proposed in the Planning commissions recommendation better meet the direction provided by-these criteria and other locally adopted policies, and need established in p of the Metro Plan and technical supporting documents, such as the "Economic Working Papers.' 1. Size - The approximately 200 -acre special-light i ndustri'al site in the Commission's recommendation is in one ownership and can provide s -i ti ng potential for a major user. This would add a second site to the L i-ty' s potential inventory of speci a l - industrial sites in excess of 150 acres in size, thereby providing greater degree of choice for major firms seeking potential sites in the City. Because the special -light industrial site identified in the Metro Plan is split into about twenty separate parcels (not all of which are under one ownership) , it may be less desirable by a potential major firm. 1 2. Access - while Alternative #2 currently has access to a major arterial (west 11th Avenue) , upon extension of the proposed arterial facility south from Bel tl i ne Road, the access to the special -light industrial site in the Planning Commission's recommendation would be superior. 3. Surrounding Uses - The topography of the site in Alternative #1 provides natural buffering from existing transitional heavy industrial uses to the north. 4. Campus -Like Environment - Some firms do prefer gently rolling topographical condi tans . The site in Alternative #1 contains this type of condi tan . In addition, the site in Alternative #1 would provide unobstructed views to the scenic forested hills to the south, and the natural wetlands area to the east. In addition to the points noted above, by shifting the special light industrial site to the center of the Basin, the Planning Commission's recommendation provides a residential land use arrangement which more efficiently to goals and policies of the community pertaining to balanced land use, transportation and compact urban growth. This occurs through clustering of the multiple family land uses around the major service and employment centers, i . e . commercial and industrial l and uses. F. Eugene Economic Diversification Program. On September 23, 1981, the Eugene city Council adopted the City's Six -Point Diversification Program. That document outlines six specific actions the City will embark upon to diversify the local economy. Those points are: 1 ) i ndustri al siting; core area development; small business assistance; destination point activities; employment and training programs; and cap.i tal improvement projects. Two of these six points are particularly pertinent to the W i l l o w Creek Special Area Study. Point 1 - industrial siting - anticipates provision of a variety of siting opportunities for industrial firms which wish to expand or locate in the community. Point 6 - capital improvement projects - identifies continued improvement and expansion of the City's - i of ra structure as critical to diversification of the local economic base. The W i l l o w Creek study, both through policy and proposed land-use configurations, directly responds to these points. The Basin is identified in the Metro Plan as an important growth area of the metropolitan community. It includes land which is contained within the adopted urban growth boundary (which is appropriate for extension of key urban services as the metropolitan area grows), and land identified as urban reserve (which is identified for extension of the urban growth boundary beyond the planning period of the Metro Plan). Both the urban growth boundary and urban reserve areas of the of the Willow Creek Basin are shown on Map B of the Study document. G. 2000 Transportation Plan (T- 2000). The areawi de transportation plan, T-2000, is a functional plan intended to guide development of transportation facilities to serve the metropolitan area. It emphasizes streets and highways as the backbone of , M1100 the area's transportation facilities for the next twenty years. It also focuses on pol i es intended to maximize the capacity of existing and future facilities by suggesting land-use arrangements and capital improvements which may encourage the use of alternate modes of transportation, such as bicycling, walking, pa ratran s i t and transit. The W i l l o w Creek Special Area study responds to this direction by providing draft policies which will guide capital improvements in the' Basin and land -use arrangements which will encourage alternative transportation modes. pl j finelg epl ng ATTACHMENT B TO RESOLUTION NO, 3699 OF THE CITY OF EUGENE. OREGON In addition to the specific findings referenced, in Resolution No. 3699, the City Council of the City of Eugene adopts the follow- ing supplemental findings to justify the Metropolitan Area General Plan amendment and adoption of the willow Creek Special Area Study: 10 LCDC Goal 1 (Citizen Involvement). (a) Further proceedings for citizen involvement have occurred through public hearings before the Lane County Planning Commission and Board of County Commis- sioners and the City of Springfield Planning Commission and City Council. 20 LCDC Goal Z .Land Use Planning} . (a) An additional working paper not referenced in the initial findings provides further evidentiary support for the plan amendment and special area study adoption, the Draft Technical Supplement to the Metro- politan Area General Plan, issued in June, 1982. (b) The Urbanization Goal, LCDC Goal 14, is not directly applicable to the subject plan amendment. No change in the urban growth boundary is proposed by this plan amendment. The assumptions. findings and con- clusions in the Metropolitan Area General Plan and its supporting documents offer further legal and factual justification for this plan amendment and special area study -adoption. (c) The process of a discrete plan amendment in connection -with the adoption of the W' llow Creek Spe- - vial Area Study does not open for reconsideration all of the decisions reached in the enactment of the general plan. Two suggestions were made in the course of the plan amendment proceedings for additional plan amend- ments: expansion of the urban growth boundary to include property owned by Mr, Gordon Elliott; and, removal of the special light industrial designation from the west Park property. Neither of these sites are within the geographic area of this special area study and are, therefore, beyond the scope, 1 e ga 1 ly and factually, of these proceedings. The action requested by each of these proponents may be initiated by applications for privately - initiated plan amendments. (d) The expansion of the amount of land desig- nated as special light industrial within the Willow Creek area is necessitated by City, experience in nego- Attachment B -- Page 1 tiating for the location of large light industrial firms in the City. These experiences suggest that a 200 acre .site is needed for companies of a parti- cular size. The lack of choice in the metropolitan area for sites of this size requires the addition of such a parcel to the industrial land supply. (e) The willow Creek area is the best location for placing such a large special light industrial site because: ( 1) It is in the general area of the City where a number of special light industrial sites have been planned; (2) Considerable interest has existed in the new special light industrial site by Hewlett -- Packard. Irrespective of the outcome of these discussions the negotiations revealed the market advantages of this site compared with other special light industrial designated and non- - designated parcels in the metropolitan area; (3 ) Creation of a major employment base in the willow Creep area which is largely un- developed) will allow integrated and comprehen- sive planning around that employment center. This integrated planning is more attainable with the special light industrial site in the interior of the willow Creek Basin; (.4) other available parcels sufficient in size to meet industrial land demand of this quality are not as desirable as the one desig- nated in-the plan amendment. They are not located in proximity with the other special light industrial parcels, are not within the urban growth boundary and areas that can be readily serviced Ce.g. Elliott parcel), and -f ai 1 to offer the same opportunity for inte- grated planning with adjacent or nearby resi- dential, commercial and public land uses. The location of the special light industrial site within the willow Creek Basin responds to and is consistent with these policy directions provided in the Metropolitan Area General Plan; (5) From a larger planning perspective, the willow Creek Basin is the logical place for urbanization for Eugene. Expansion of the metropolitan area to the north would require large scale conversion of agricultural land; expansion to the south and southeast would Attachment B - Page 2 spawn development of the South Hills, an impor. tant urban buf f Bring area, and create sign i f i cant sewer and urban services delivery problems; and, expansion to the northwest creates a potential future compatibility problem with the airport operations there. �.f } The expansion of special light industrial land supply within the Willow Creek Basin from a 95 acre bifurcated site with 8 ownerships to a single 230 acre site in one ownership does not require re- examina- tion of the number or location of other special light industrial sites in the metropolitan area for the following reasons: (1) The number of special light industrial sites Uive) designated for Eugene in the Metro Plan is not a direct function of immediate land use demand or employment demand but is a result of determinations reached in the Metro Plan as to the amount, size, and location of special light industrial sites needed to create a market for such potential users, Replacement of a 95 acre parcel with a 230 acre parcel still leaves a need for 3 sites in the loo - 120 acre parcel size. No evidence was presented in the hearings on this plan amendment that such a supply is not needed. (.Parenthetically, the table at page B -3 of the June 14 memorandum contains a mis- statement. The number of owners for the Cone - Breeden tract is 3 rather than 1.) (2 ) Should future events prove that an over- - supply of special light industrial sites exist, cure may occur through the plan amendment process. 03 The elimination of the special light industrial designation for the South llth (willow Creek) light industrial site is not mutually ex. clusive with the elimination of such designation on the west Park site should evidence be presented that an oversupply exists. In the absence of such evidence, redesignation of the west llth site is preferred over other sites because the West llth does not meet the special, light indus- trial site criteria in the Metro Plan as well as other sites. It is held in larger number of ownerships, adjacent to limited transportation facilities in an area which is less buffered from detracting urban uses offering less opportunity for a "campus -like atmosphere ", than other spe- cial light industrial sites. Attachment B -- Pace 3 (g) Sufficient time for citizen involvement, collection of necessary factual information, refine- ment of issues and strategies, and identification and resolution of conflicts with other governmental units has been alloted in this plan amendment process. Several public hearings have occurred before Eugene, Springfield, Lane County, and L -COG . NoIntergovern -- mental conflicts have been 'Identified, And the fact- ual analysis in support of the Metro Plan which was developed, with citizen imput, over an extensive period of time. No broad citizen opposition to these changes has occurred which might necessitate a longer evaluation period. Submission of the plan amendment together with the Metro Plan for LCDC acknowledgment in August, 1982, will allow, if the plans are acknow- ledged, greater certainty in the short run for indus- trial locations and urban services extensions. (h) coordination of the draft plan' has occurred with affected governmental agencies through referral and comment. These include: EwEB; Lane Electric; School District 4J; Lane County Public works; and, DCLDO 3. LCDC Goal 5 (Open Spaces) . (a) The plan amendment relies upon the same con- flict resolution process for Goal 5 as contained in the Metro Plan. The switch in locations of special light industrial sites will not affect the accomoda -- tion reached in the Metro Plan for Goal 5 concerns in the willow Creek Basin. (b) Special treatment for the wetlands area is provided in the text of the subarea plan as amended, including but not limited to, early annexation for resource protection. (c) Special review will be given to the hydro- logy of the willow Creek Basin prior to development as explained in Policy C -3. 4, LCDC Goal 6 (Air, water and Land Resources) (a) Minimal, if any, differences in automobile emissions will exist by selection of an employment - intensive land use scheme over a residential scenerio. (b) Residential effluent discharge will be roughly equal to the discharge potential for the em- ployment-intensive land use arrangement for which the plan is amended. Attachment B - Page 4 (c) Annexation and urban development wi11 only occur upon satisfactory provision of urban services. 50 LCDC Coal 11 (Public Facilities and Services), (a) The timing and costs of public services ex- tensions to the Willow Creek Basin are discussed at pp. 5 - 7 of the July 21, 1982 staff report incorpor- ated herein. (b) The City of Eugene is committed in its capital improvements program to provision of sanitary sewer service to this area in the near future, ( c ) The alternative mechanisms for payment of these capital expenses are discussed in the staff re- port and include : payment from the general fund, a capital improvements tax increment district or a spe- cial systems development charge. It is reasonable to expect additional property tax revenues from devel- opment within the Basin as that urbanization progresses. (d) Development of the Willow Creek Basin will be less costly than development of other areas within and outside the City to the immediate north, to the west, or to the south - southeast. To the extent land must be available for additional economic growth, the Willow Creek Basin is a logical and economic place for that growth to occur. Attachment B - Page 5 . ATTACHMENT B -2 TO RESOLUTION N0. M E M O R A N D U M .3699 OF THE CITY OF EUGENE, OR July 21, 1982 To: Mayor and Council From: Planning Department Subj : WILLOW CREEK SPECIAL AREA STUDY -- COUNCIL ACTION I. Overview On July 14, 1982 the Council conducted its public hearing on the Willow Creek Special Area Study. As a result of those hearings, and Council discussion, the staff was directed to prepare a series of possible modifications to the text of the draft document for consideration at the meeting of July 21. Those changes, as well as those which were recommended to the Council by the Planning Commission, are included in this memorandum. Text changes are shown in legislative format with underline indicating additions and parenthesis ( ) indicating deletions. An adopting resolution and a revised set of findings will be forwarded to the Council by courier. II. Chan es Recommended By Planning Commission The fol l owi -ng changes to the draft were recommended to the Council by the Planning Commission. I. Modify the explanation of policy A -1, pages 4 and 5 to read, "This policy is consistent with other policies in the Metropolitan Plan which provide for annexation of industrial land in conjunction with an It approved capital improvement program that outlines provision of sanitary sewer service to an area. The Metro Plan policy also provides for interim sanitary sewer service through acceptable (to both the city and developer) facilities, such as sewage lagoons, when a permanent servicing plan has been established through an adopted capital improvement program. Adoption of the City's capital improvement program for FY 1982--83, which identifies the Test Eugene Trunk as Eugene's highest priority for capital improvements, helps fulfill this policy direction. Finally, the Metro Plan contains policy language (policy #23, page III -B -S, Aug. 1980 Metro Plan and policy #18, page 25 and 19, page 6, 1982 Plan Amendments) which support an aggresi ve annexation program and servicing of designated industrial lands in order to have a sufficient supply of "development ready" land. In addition, this of i cy responds to Eugene's own economic diversification efforts as outlined in "Eugene's Economic Di versi fication Program," 5e t.3 1981 which identifies industrial s i ti n as one strate y to improve the economic conditions of the community . 2 . Polic y A -Z, page 5, change to read, "Exce t as s eci al ly provided in Pol-i cy E -3 annexation of commercial and residential land shall be deferred at least until sanitary sewer service is available to the area, and other Eugene annexation requirements are met." 3 • Policy ­D -1, page 9, under explanation, change to read, "The community resource node concept is intended to maximize public investment by providing land for facilities which can be shared by various public, q u a s i - p u b l i c , anal appropriate private activities. Under this concept, Eugene would acqui r -e land for the public- resource node, U14i making it available to various users, i ncl u a ro ri ate social service agencies Ultimately, siting r of Y the elementary school facility must be approved by the School Board of District 4J taking g into account location of other existing schools, attendance boundaries and other pertinent factors. In any event, the proposed future acquisition of this property should not be used to sto p development Plans when other appropriate, public criteria have been sati sfi - ed , The public resource node on the Plan Diagram is merel meant to schematically demonstrate this con ce and is not meant to be site s pecific. 4._ Policy E -3, page 10, change to read, 'The City of Eugene shall encourage annexation of the wetlands area and properties under contiguous ownership in order to facilitate agreements for public management between the property owners and The Nature Conservancy. In the short term a non -urban zoning cl as si f i cation, such as AG, Agriculture and Grazing, shall be applied to these properties (until they are needed for urban l evel s of development) until app conditions have been met to for urban level o meat . i ' — 5. Page 18, Introduction to Section VII, add a new paragraph, "The lan di a ram, adopted as art of this Special Study Study is intended to conceptually identify land-use arrangements in the Basin, which would ultimately be implemented Ly other more s eci f i c ubl i c actions For 1 the ubl i c resource node on the � plan a diagram _m i s shown instance: �._ _ �. schematically to demonstrate the intent of the conceit, - and is not meant to be site specific; Q nei hborhood commercial facilities be located in residential areas as _part of the rocess of urbanization; and �J zonin and other implementation techni ues will be used to s eci fi cal ly def i ne l and -use arr ements suggested by the plan dia 6. Add a new second paragraph to the Introduction Section, page 1, to read as follows: "This study is in several sections as noted on the receedi n Table of Contents The first section lists the summary of the study and p olicies being recommended . Each i ndi vi dual policy is followed by a brief discussion of the policy. Additional background information for the policies as well as further discussion of the land use alternatives and el ements of the Willow Creek Basin are found in latter sections of the Study Policies are adopted by the City Council as .. guidance for deci si on--mak� nq related to the Plan era a . City ro rams, actions and decisions such as zone chap es, traffic p attern changes, and capital improvements will be evaluated on the basis of their ability to implement the - se pvl i ci es as well as other adop City vq_al s and policies. Because . . t_ heY are adopted by the Council as the City's wide for action olicies are the most important statements in the Stud . 7. On pages 5 and 6, modify the explanatory paragraph as follows "On g P , property, with slopes and elevations which fit criteria to apply planned unit development procedures outlined in the South Hills Study, the PUD procedures (should) shall include direction to: 1 minimize the effects of development on visual assets; 2} cluster development away from potential and identified problem soils slopes and geologic conditions; and P 3} maximize ze retent� on of existing ng vegetation. On properti in or adjacent to designated natural areas, the PUD procedures (should) shall include direction to: 1 transfer residential densities from natural resource areas to buildable C C portions of tax lots; 2) control storm drainage -- quantity and quality - -- consequences on the natural area; and 3) use buffering techniques such as vegetative landscape barrier or fencing to protect the natural resource values of the -site. On properties bordering 9 stream courses, the PUD, cluster subdivision or site review procedures (should) shall include direction for retention of natural vegetation and buffering of the stream courses from development. This policy recognizes that under Eugene's planned unit development regulations, a variety of structure types and other neighborhood uses such as "neighborhood commercial" are allowed in any residential areas." 8. Page 19, under Public Resource Node discussion, change second sentence to read as follows, "while these types of facilities are generally available within the community, this proposal conceives of them being clustered in one area and located in ,proximity to other hi h- intensity land uses in the Basin" . 9. Page 25, under Plants and Wildlife, change the first sentence in the second paragraph to read, "At least three rare plants (including the Aster curti s) do exist in the wet natural resource area of the Basin (see Map H)." 10. Page 23, Under Discussion of Size, change second sentence to read, "The special light industrial site in Alternative #2 is split into approximately (two 50 . acre pieces) sixteen separate arcel s, possibly rendering it less desirable by a potential major firm. 11. Map E in the draft document, change to include footnote for Public Resource Node, and addition of high-density residential south of commercial designation (see revised Map E attached) . 12. Modify Map B in the draft Willow Creek special Area Study to show Eugene's City limits line (see revised Map B attached) . 13. In the analysis of consistency with Statewide Goals, add a new paragraph to the Goal 5 discussion which would read as follows: Early annexation of the industrially designated land and wetlands area is to fulfill the local oal s of provi-di ng a sufficient su ly of development-ready industrial l and and to p rotect a Goal 5 resource As Land Use Pol i cy 2 provi conversion of the remainder of the basin from urbani zabl e to urban 1 and wi l I be deferred Addition of this paragraph will strengthen the Goal 5 analysis. III. Modifications Re By Council The following modifications are staff proposals in response to Council direction at the meeting of Ju ly 14. p 1. Change Policy E--3 (page In of the draft report) to read: (The City of Eugene shall encourage annexation of the wetlands area and properties under contiguous ownership in order to facilitiate agreements for public management between the property owners and The Nature Conservancy. In the short-term a non-urban zoning c l a s s i f i c a t i o n , such AG, Agriculture and Grazing, shall be applied to these properties until they are needed for urban levels of development.) In o_ rder to facilitate agreements for rotecti on and public management of the Iii 11 ow Creek wetl ands _area, the City of Eu ene will initiate annexation of the wetlands area and conti uousl owned buildable properties provided the three affected property owners agree to such action. In the short--term, a non -urban zonin cl assi fi cati,v , such as AG, a ri cul ture and Grazin District-, shall be a lied to these properties until 4Rpropriate conditions have been met to p_rovi de for urban development. 2. Change the explanation of policy C -3 (page 8 of the draft Report) to read Experience shows that increased urbanization will result in the necessity to improve storm runoff facilities. In this case, the existing Amazon Channel will become part of the major storm run- off system for the Basin. (Further analysis will) A thorough analysis shall indicate if ultimate urbanization of the Willow Creek Basin will result in capacity or flow problems, and if so, what remedial actions are necessary. Implementation measures should attempt to balance protection of bottoml and in the Basin from storm run -off against the need for maintenance of appropriate moisture levels ( quantity and quality) for vegetation in the natural area. 3. Add an additional financial section to the draft report which would read as follows, X. FINANCING Development of the W i l l o w Creek Basin represents the equivalent of construction of a new city. At ultimate development, the Basin could provide homes for about 20,000 people, and places of employment for about 17,500 employees. This represents a city with a population roughly equivalent to the cities of Milwaukee, Hillsboro or Albany (1980 populations) and employment approximately equal to the combined levels of Albany and Millersburg. These comparisons suggest that costs of providing services to the entire Basin can appropriately be reviewed in the .context of capital costs required to develop a new medium size city in Oregon. Information obtained from the Bureau of Governmental Research, at the University of Oregon, indicates that the total estimatated value of the fixed assets inventory for the City of Hillsboro, 1981 population of 28,650, is roughly $32.5 million. This excludes costs for schools, electrical distribution systems, and transit facilities. significantly this estimate is generally based on acquisition costs and not replacement costs. It can be estimated that actual replacement costs could double the total value of the fixed asset inventory, i . e . repl acment cost could be about $65 million. Table 5 indicates that costs for delivery of services to the Basin (excludin schools,-electrical distribution systems and transit facilities are currently y estimated to be about $26.5 - $28.5 million (1982 dollars) . A. Estimated Service Costs In Willow Creek Table 5 shows estimated costs by component and service which will ultimately be involved in providing service to the W i l l o w Creek Basin. 5 � C Table 5 Costs For Services In Willow Creek (1982 $OOOs) Service Component school Sewers Parks Transp Fire El ec /Water Elementary 5000 -7000 Storm 1100 Sanitary 2400 Pub Resource 1250 -1500 Node Neighborhood 625 -750 Park Community 2000-3000 Center Streets Transit Sta Eq u i p /Remode 1 Electricity Transmission Water Transmission 11500 - 350 -400 8130 5475 Park Development 2000 -2500 These estimates reflect a broad overview of potential public service delivery requirements based on preliminary layout and design concepts which may change in the context of specific development proposals. The e sti mates in Table 5 indicate that the total costs of providing a full range of services to the Basin, at full - -development, could be approximately $40 - $44 mil (in 1952 dol Data in Table 5 does not inc costs for facilities outside the Basin which will be used to serve the area at fu deve These data suggest that based on estimated replacement value of the fixed asset inventory of the City of Hillsboro, delivery of services to the Basin may be 40 percent of the cost of delivering comparable services in the City of Hillsboro, i . e . the estimated costs of services for the Basin excl udi n t 9 schools, electrical di stributi on system and transit facilities are $26.5 - $28.5 million compared to an estimated $65 million for rep lacement of similar services in the City of Hillsboro. This ref the fact that many existing Eugene can be used to facilities i n Eu g meet the public e serve ce needs of the B asin. . For instance, the regional treatment center, fire and of i ce dispatch atch faci l'i ti e p p s all are in -place and available for use by the residents and businesses in the Basin. Other savi ngs, such as the use of existing Fire Station #1C (immediately U, r to the east of the Basin) contribute to the savings in public expenditures for capital projects needed to service the Basin. This demonstrates that the nodal development approach to urbanization, in the context of an already developed City, can be a cost - effective method of dealing with required public expenditures for capital projects. B. Revenue Table 5, does not identify sources of funds for development of the Basin. The potential exists for funding participation by other agencies besides the City of Eugene. As in all other newly developing areas of the City, Eugene will be required to provide a substantial share of the funds needed to construct the infrastructure outlined in Table 5. There are now three basic directions open to the City to provide a long-term funding mechanism for these facilities: 1. The City could rely on the general fund to provide the majority of revenue sources needed construct capital facilities in the Basin. 2. The City could institute a mechanism which earmarks new tax revenues 'generated from new construction in the Basin for construction of capital facilities (a capital projects tax increment district) . 3. The City could i .n sti tute a special systems development charge for application to new construction in the Basin, with the intent of using these funds for development of public capital improvements in Willow Creek. 3. Add new policy B-2, to read as follows: The City of Eugene shall investigate new methods of financing capital projects required for development of the Willow Creek Basin. As development occurs in the willow Creek Basin, public financing of capital projects will 'be required. while these capital improvements will occur over a long period of time, identification of the appropriate revenue mechanisms to provide the required financing can occur in the near future. Through the Council Revenue and Resources Committee, these mechanisms might be put in place in time for the C'ity' s FY 1983-84 Budget. Examples of mechanisms which could be employed by Eugene might include continued use of general fund sources, earmarki -ng of new tax revenues generated from new construction in the Basin for construction of capital projects in the Basin, or special systems development charges applied to new construction in the Basin and earmarked for construction of public capital improvements in Willow Creek. The Revenue and Resource Committee should also investigate funding for capital projects which could be generated in new relationships with cooperating public jurisdictions and the private sector as well as the City of Eugene. EPLNG PLJFMEM4 1 MAP B � METRO PLAN BOUNDARIES o•••o"•o CITY L191AtTS URBAN RESERVE r.r..rrr..r URBAN GROWTH BOUNDARY •- -•�- -� PLAN BOUNDARY (ridgeline) � Q is€ .. ? � °� € € s� cc arc y, ail Q W SSEE� c3�f2'Ei.iEEFeE ?EEESiE:: ;..::� eE ca Z ii::ii� °i� i:Fiii °SiifEEiiiE:Ei::i � r J !!�r''=!F�MiMliif'i W f� = J EST 1 ITH AVE. ... ............. ........ . ............. a ............ i.. 0 ... ........ I., ... ............. p e z lEieiEEEiir3::Eii EE ii:Ei9 w �y� � .......... � J a W ........... .......... ... ... ........... .... ............................... ..... ............................... cr. r:::ESE............... S:E3. � €E � E� c °�� E� €€ E € €s ' � � f t::::: E ::::................ .:::...:::..................... u j °ii Ei i� ' Co ii ::iEEEiii�tE::iEiEEi:iii:iEi ::ii .. ............................... y .. ... ' ..........�i 2_ SSE iEEi :EiS:::F::::;;;iEiiii� i:Sii::2EEi::::::;; '�ii:��i':iii� iiiiiiE�c::iiiiiii ......... F�i:':' ��� i :.. ....::: € `:. .� s � s i �A moll I [�I .'rl li %i■ I LLI 2= (D C) *+ V ) L C.D C) C-) Llj ,� J � � Q A � V) cm LL c 0 v cc LIJ C:) L M C c > z 40 E dwo V) 0 ti. co C) <1C CD 4 0 0- V) LL CL cm.w a EO Q C3 ID in Us Z 0 z w 0 CL CL 0 . (1) m 0 z fl. uj = r- Ln a. u w w Q oll iw Md